Venezuela in the Mercosur
And Chavez campaigns fast on it
Thursday 8, July 2004
This is live writing folks. As I type Chavez is having yet a cadena. The topic? Venezuela's inclusion as an associate member of the Mercosur.
First I am a little bit surprised at it since a few months ago someone in the Mercosur said that if Venezuela wanted to engage in new trade obligations it should start by fulfilling the one it already has with other trade associations. But Chavez has been pushing through and through to get into the Mercosur for political reasons: anything to escape any trade deal with the US....
Anyway, an ailing Mercosur relented and decided to let in as associate state Venezuela and Mexico. After all, Peru and Colombia are already negotiating so it is not a big surprise that at some point all of South America will integrate into some trade block. Chavez has no problem making all sort of promises to his Southern colleagues (one day we will find out about the bill, as there is no open information on the negotiating positions of Venezuela and the Mercosur, if it is getting advantageous terms, is certainly not going to herald them!)
This is yet another golden propaganda opportunity and Chavez did not miss it. So tonight, barely hours after the announcement was made, a cadena showed us a smiling Chavez with a few well chosen clips from the different leaders praising Venezuela. These comments certainly were part of a general pattern of mutual pleasantness, but the montage of Chavez press people coupled with his explanations made them sound as if he were some kind of Messiah bringing in the leadership of the glorious bolivarian revolution (The president of Paraguay actually mentioned Venezuela new full and silly name). I wonder what Lula would think if he had time to watch such nonsense...
There was actually an interesting moment that Chavez tried to twist into his favor, though I am not sure it will work. Chile's president, Lagos, (who by the way is negotiating real well with the US Devil while inside the Mercosur) has been gingerly dealing with Chavez for quite a while. Even Chilean socialist don't buy Chavez populism. Well, while he was welcoming Chavez he was congratulating him on his political courage for accepting to go to a referendum. And right then added that the Mercosur should send observers, a lot of them, to witness such a fine moment, to learn from it themselves, help Venezuela to decide in peace and the losing side to accept the verdict.
The translation from "diplomatese" is: OK Chavez, we are watching you. We know what you are up to but you will not get away with it. You better have clean elections and certifiable results
If you doubt my translation read about the tense relationships between Lagos and Chavez for the past 2 years. Actually socialist Lagos administration and initiatives are probably the ones most at odds with Chavez goals. And Chile is the country doing the best, by far, in South America, something surely that irks Chavez a lot.
Chavez as a wily politician decided to preempt anything by interpreting Lagos's words as "see! In south America they know what is going on in Venezuela! I wish the opposition would understand that it must play the democratic game" while we all know that the opposition is the one asking for international observers while the pro Chavez Electoral Board is trying its outmost to block them! The nerve! Do chavistas buy that crap? I find it hard to believe...
Actually I think that the Mercosur is playing a trick on Chavez. This one is having more and more problems with Lula and Kirchener since last February when they saw first hand themselves the violence in Caracas. I bet that they decided to let Chavez in as a way to force him to have a fair referendum on August (and perhaps hoping to get rid of him). After all the agreement is only to welcome Venezuela and there are a lot of negotiations still to come. If indeed it is a propaganda tool for Chavez it is also a noose for his neck as he will not be able to refuse the observers that Lagos et al. will send.
Friday, July 09, 2004
Wednesday, July 07, 2004
FAIRNESS IN THE USE OF THE MEDIA IN VENEZUELA
Is the world watching?
Wednesday 7, July 2004
There is a certain group of people outside of Venezuela that have made a career in criticizing the role of the private media (1). I wonder what they will think after Monday's events. That night I wrote about the rather scandalous use of politics in the military parade for the Independence Day of Venezuela, that is, the independence days of ALL Venezuelans. But it seems that we are reaching fast a situation where some Venezuelans are more Venezuelan than others.
The reactions have not been long in coming. From Zamora, one of the directors of the Electoral Board CNE (2) to the searing editorial of Tal Cual. This editorial has been already partially translated by Miguel.
Another searing editorial can be found in EL Universal from the pen of Roberto Giusti who I have translated in the past. Time does not allow me but this snippet:
But an undaunted Chavez had no qualms in calling for yet two more "cadenas" on Tuesday, one to let the people now that thousands of people sworn in as new Venezuelan citizens were with the revolution, and the other, a long one at lunch time, to graduate a new crop of officers from the diverse military institutions and of course implying to them that they were there to serve the revolution. How? By reminding them that they started school in August 1999 as the New constitutional debate took place and thus they were the first real Bolivarian promotion.
To complete the picture there is a festival of sorts that is held at our opera house, the Teresa Carreno theatre (3). The name of the Festival is "Venezuela no está sola: Florentino sin fronteras" (Venezuela is not alone: Florentino without borders). That would not be so bad after all, except that this is the title of the campaign commando of Chavez. But it gets better, passing this for news, the state TV has been passing live the sessions where speaker after speaker launches into tirades after tirades of lauds to the Bolivarian revolution, also known as Chavez, El Supremo.
But the world is listening indeed, not the way Chavez would like to. In spite of all the incessantly heard complaints that the private media in Venezuela are unfairly criticizing him, in spite of all the cadenas he subjects us to, in spite of the non stop propaganda channel that the state TV, VTV, has become in violation of the electoral codes published a few days ago, it seems that Chavez message is not crossing well overseas.
In an unambiguous interview with Andres Oppenheimer, Kerry was quite clear on what Chavez represents. If Kerry is elected, Washington might become even of a worse nightmare for Chavez. The Miami Herald reports also on this Kerry stance (here if link expired, and in Spanish in El Universal).
Poor Eva Golinger, she will indeed have to vote for Nader now. Damn Liberals! They cannot be trusted! (4) It isunfortunatee that so many Liberals have tied the knot with Chavez realizing only too late the true nature of the regime.
As the VIO files reported, and as all evidences point out to, VIO files or not, the work of the chavista defenders outside Venezuela does not seem to be paying off. At least, the ones that count do not need to watch CNN anymore, they know what is going on here.
Thus we are left with the initial question: where is the fairness in news reporting? As the private media is visibly making an effort to invite more often chavismo to its talk shows, the chavsita media not only is far from inviting opposition folks over (at least I have not seen any in the recent days) but it is becoming an all and out propaganda machine at tax payer expense. And cadenas are already reaching a paroxysm when there is still a full month of campaign left.
Critics of Venezuelan private media would be well advised these coming days to watch their commnents as they could lose their credibility. The state information machinery seems to be poised to outdo all the mistakes made by the private media in recent years.
------------------
(1) Quite a crew, from Le Monde Diplomatique where Lemoine seems unable to speak of anything else, to the usual crew represented in Venezuelanalisis, in particulars Weisbrot now promoted to pro Chavez witness in US Senate hearings. They all try to convince us that all the problems of Chavez come only from a partial media.
(2) The main two chavista directors in the CNE have curiously traveled to the USA for some meeting to defend their position and try to validate their work at the head of Venezuela. This at a time when significant delays are being experienced in the organization of the Recall Election, not to mention other due elections. As the days pass it seems less and less likely that the 15 August date will be made, which would have tremendous consequences.
(3) Current chavista propaganda now claims that the opera "ahora es del pueblo". Indeed, it is used for all sorts of political activities by chavismo, with nobody knowing whether rental fees are paid, etc, etc… This as culture in Venezuela is going through one of its worst crisis, under the excuse that the people are the one that hold the real culture. The result is that there is no culture left, popular or not. As could have been predicted.
(4) It is indeed very amusing to see all these US supporters of Chavez rather upset with the Kerry positions. Clear ones at that. Probably they are unable to understand that there is such a thing as National Interests that go above party lines, a concept totally alien a an El Supremo regime like the one they defend.
Is the world watching?
Wednesday 7, July 2004
There is a certain group of people outside of Venezuela that have made a career in criticizing the role of the private media (1). I wonder what they will think after Monday's events. That night I wrote about the rather scandalous use of politics in the military parade for the Independence Day of Venezuela, that is, the independence days of ALL Venezuelans. But it seems that we are reaching fast a situation where some Venezuelans are more Venezuelan than others.
The reactions have not been long in coming. From Zamora, one of the directors of the Electoral Board CNE (2) to the searing editorial of Tal Cual. This editorial has been already partially translated by Miguel.
Another searing editorial can be found in EL Universal from the pen of Roberto Giusti who I have translated in the past. Time does not allow me but this snippet:
Anyway, nothing new but with all the old one notch higher in tone, on a national day used for electoral demagoguery and to feed the insatiable vanity of the boss. A National Assembly and State Institutions transformed in adulatory sheep together with the tamed Armed Forces offered a pathetic note in the memorable epic to celebrate I do not know which independence.
But an undaunted Chavez had no qualms in calling for yet two more "cadenas" on Tuesday, one to let the people now that thousands of people sworn in as new Venezuelan citizens were with the revolution, and the other, a long one at lunch time, to graduate a new crop of officers from the diverse military institutions and of course implying to them that they were there to serve the revolution. How? By reminding them that they started school in August 1999 as the New constitutional debate took place and thus they were the first real Bolivarian promotion.
To complete the picture there is a festival of sorts that is held at our opera house, the Teresa Carreno theatre (3). The name of the Festival is "Venezuela no está sola: Florentino sin fronteras" (Venezuela is not alone: Florentino without borders). That would not be so bad after all, except that this is the title of the campaign commando of Chavez. But it gets better, passing this for news, the state TV has been passing live the sessions where speaker after speaker launches into tirades after tirades of lauds to the Bolivarian revolution, also known as Chavez, El Supremo.
But the world is listening indeed, not the way Chavez would like to. In spite of all the incessantly heard complaints that the private media in Venezuela are unfairly criticizing him, in spite of all the cadenas he subjects us to, in spite of the non stop propaganda channel that the state TV, VTV, has become in violation of the electoral codes published a few days ago, it seems that Chavez message is not crossing well overseas.
In an unambiguous interview with Andres Oppenheimer, Kerry was quite clear on what Chavez represents. If Kerry is elected, Washington might become even of a worse nightmare for Chavez. The Miami Herald reports also on this Kerry stance (here if link expired, and in Spanish in El Universal).
In a televised interview that will air Wednesday in 19 Latin America countries, Kerry called the upcoming referendum in Venezuela ''a real challenge to the entire hemisphere'' and said that ''as president,'' he would ``work with the international community to bring pressure in the interest of democracy.
''Global transparency, accountability of government, democracy, I think is critical everywhere, but particularly to our hemisphere,'' Kerry said in the interview with Herald columnist Andres Oppenheimer for the TV program Oppenheimer Presenta. ``If Chavez does not respect that process, then he makes himself an outlaw with respect to those values and those interests.''
Poor Eva Golinger, she will indeed have to vote for Nader now. Damn Liberals! They cannot be trusted! (4) It isunfortunatee that so many Liberals have tied the knot with Chavez realizing only too late the true nature of the regime.
As the VIO files reported, and as all evidences point out to, VIO files or not, the work of the chavista defenders outside Venezuela does not seem to be paying off. At least, the ones that count do not need to watch CNN anymore, they know what is going on here.
Thus we are left with the initial question: where is the fairness in news reporting? As the private media is visibly making an effort to invite more often chavismo to its talk shows, the chavsita media not only is far from inviting opposition folks over (at least I have not seen any in the recent days) but it is becoming an all and out propaganda machine at tax payer expense. And cadenas are already reaching a paroxysm when there is still a full month of campaign left.
Critics of Venezuelan private media would be well advised these coming days to watch their commnents as they could lose their credibility. The state information machinery seems to be poised to outdo all the mistakes made by the private media in recent years.
------------------
(1) Quite a crew, from Le Monde Diplomatique where Lemoine seems unable to speak of anything else, to the usual crew represented in Venezuelanalisis, in particulars Weisbrot now promoted to pro Chavez witness in US Senate hearings. They all try to convince us that all the problems of Chavez come only from a partial media.
(2) The main two chavista directors in the CNE have curiously traveled to the USA for some meeting to defend their position and try to validate their work at the head of Venezuela. This at a time when significant delays are being experienced in the organization of the Recall Election, not to mention other due elections. As the days pass it seems less and less likely that the 15 August date will be made, which would have tremendous consequences.
(3) Current chavista propaganda now claims that the opera "ahora es del pueblo". Indeed, it is used for all sorts of political activities by chavismo, with nobody knowing whether rental fees are paid, etc, etc… This as culture in Venezuela is going through one of its worst crisis, under the excuse that the people are the one that hold the real culture. The result is that there is no culture left, popular or not. As could have been predicted.
(4) It is indeed very amusing to see all these US supporters of Chavez rather upset with the Kerry positions. Clear ones at that. Probably they are unable to understand that there is such a thing as National Interests that go above party lines, a concept totally alien a an El Supremo regime like the one they defend.
Tuesday 6, July 2004
I have been sick all through the long week end. Thus I could not go out to check on the disaster that has happened to my home town. I did not report earlier on it as I was hoping to take some pictures myself of find some article from the Caracas newspapers, but we are so far from Caracas…
Rainy season has started early this year and it has been raining almost every day since Easter. All is now green and lush, and water logged. On Sunday afternoon we had a strong rain coming as usual from the Caribbean, in the Puerto Cabello/Chivacoa direction. It was a heavy rain, like the monsoon like we get 4/5 times a year in San Felipe, when in my street there is so much water that the second step of the stairs to the door is under water. And the street has a slope! But the water comes rushing from the higher part of the street in such amount that a small car could be moved. If spectacular, it is OK as the houses and street are designed for drainage.
But Sunday something happened. The rain intensity started going down, presumably as the heavy clouds keep on their way to Chivacoa. Suddenly there was a reverse in the wind direction and the rain came back from Chivacoa with a vengeance. The strong wind seemed almost like a small hurricane and the balcony of my apartment could not evacuate fast enough the water pouring through it horizontally. The water thus went under the balcony door and within 5 minutes half of my apartment was under water. I spent half an hour pushing the water to the bathroom and kitchen drainage. I thought that it was like the hurricanes I experienced in the US, maybe not a real one but something looking like one, with even an eye of sorts!
But I was the lucky one, only rain water on my floors. The water logged side of a hill gave up when the second rain wave of Sunday afternoon came in. Not a big mud slide but big enough to clog a "quebrada", the terms we use for dry river beds that fill up suddenly with water during rainy season for a few hours after a rain. The consequences was a large muddy wave that took away about 4 dozen houses, placed too close to the "quebrada El Guayabito". As far as I can tell 3 people have died or disappeared, and a few are injured and more lost their humble possessions, since as usual people that live in those areas are land squatters that are allowed to build their houses in such places. Even though the Yaracuy government is good about cleaning urban "quebradas" at rainy season, sometimes nature strikes.
I tried Monday, in spite of my cold to try to go out. But roads to the neighborhood were barred, heavy machinery was at work. The streets were full of mud, I was with sandals, a bad cold and it was drizzling. Nothing really I could do. Except for these pictures of people cleaning their street and a view of a wide avenue where I occasionally stroll on exercise walks. Today I went to work and I planned to try again but I got worse and had to come back home to rest. I will try again tomorrow but I understand that it is almost clean right now, they are only looking for the body of a 2 year old baby girl that was swept away with her uncle trying to rescue her. The body of the uncle has been found.
PS: El Universal does carry an article today with a picture of the damages.
Tuesday, July 06, 2004
Independence day in Venezuela
Independence from Spain maybe, but not from human folly and cheap patriotic posturing
Monday 5, July 2004
Well, we did celebrate another anniversary of July 5 1811 when we signed our Independence proclamation, the first South American country to do so.
What should normally be a day of Patriotic fervor was used by Chavez and his minions for campaigning purpose, to portray the opposition as "vende patrias" (sellers of the fatherland). And the electoral campaign is just starting. I wonder if the Electoral Board is going to be true to its word and start slapping a few fines on the president. I am not holding my breath.
Let's see a few samples.
Chavez started the day with the announcement that the Venezuelan people is "ready to resist". In a ceremony in front of the diplomatic corps in Venezuela he sounded as if the marines were about to land in Venezuela. Well, maybe a few in civil in the Margarita resorts. Apparently "some want to give Venezuela to foreign interests". Or what is left of it since Cuba already got quite a nice stash of our cash and foreign oil companies are getting scandalous concessions from the hands of the more than likely corrupt Ramirez at the oil ministry. At least according to representative Rondon. Which, by the way did not stop Chavez to say a few days ago that they could accuse him of corruption as they pleased, he did not care as they were the corrupt ones. Translation: you did before, now it is my turn to steal the public coffers.
The honored speaker at the solemn session of the National Assembly went on with a panegyric of Chavez that reminded those declaimed once upon a time of the leaders of Eastern Europe, or of today Fidel. The speaker was OAS ambassador Valero who has been doing its best to try to brain wash his colleagues at the OAS. Well, at least we know that his own brain has been quite washed out.
Then the stage moved on to Los Proceres, our monumental avenue built by our one before last dictator, Perez Jimenez, for military parades. Our wanna-be dictator seems to find the setting to his liking. The Army paraded today under posters that were rather political, calling for the union between the army and its people. The media was not allowed to cover the parade and we had to rely on the "cadena" that the official VTV sent us hours and hours. No important sporting event, mercifully as the Euro Cup ended yesterday and the South American one starts tomorrow.
The parade started with the reconstruction of the "batalla de Santa Ines" a rather dubious success of our mid XIX century civil wars. But it has been decided that the name of the battle would be the catch name of the present electoral campaign now that the "comando Ayacucho" floundered so badly during the Recall Election drive. So much for an impartial parade.
As a new development we saw for the first time lots of buses parked along the way, ferrying in a reliable public. Once upon a time whoever wanted to attend the July 5th parade could do so. Now, it seems that times have changed and only the blessed few can attend. An amateur video, by the way, did catch up what seemed to be students of the new Bolivarian University trained as some type of militia and made to take some buses to go to Los Proceres.
The opposition? Well, already eliminated from any National ceremony, it decided not to show up to the National Assembly solemn session. To begin with chavista supporters would have booed them if they had tried to get inside the building. But since the opposition is treated as second class citizenry and barred from any other ceremony, why bother to attend the session?
And so it goes in Venezuela where Chavez preaches suddenly a language of love and reconciliation but were the crude facts everyday contradict his discourse. Do the foreign media see these things? I think that the diplomatic corps is not fooled but sometimes I wonder about the other guys at CNN and BBC...
Independence from Spain maybe, but not from human folly and cheap patriotic posturing
Monday 5, July 2004
Well, we did celebrate another anniversary of July 5 1811 when we signed our Independence proclamation, the first South American country to do so.
What should normally be a day of Patriotic fervor was used by Chavez and his minions for campaigning purpose, to portray the opposition as "vende patrias" (sellers of the fatherland). And the electoral campaign is just starting. I wonder if the Electoral Board is going to be true to its word and start slapping a few fines on the president. I am not holding my breath.
Let's see a few samples.
Chavez started the day with the announcement that the Venezuelan people is "ready to resist". In a ceremony in front of the diplomatic corps in Venezuela he sounded as if the marines were about to land in Venezuela. Well, maybe a few in civil in the Margarita resorts. Apparently "some want to give Venezuela to foreign interests". Or what is left of it since Cuba already got quite a nice stash of our cash and foreign oil companies are getting scandalous concessions from the hands of the more than likely corrupt Ramirez at the oil ministry. At least according to representative Rondon. Which, by the way did not stop Chavez to say a few days ago that they could accuse him of corruption as they pleased, he did not care as they were the corrupt ones. Translation: you did before, now it is my turn to steal the public coffers.
The honored speaker at the solemn session of the National Assembly went on with a panegyric of Chavez that reminded those declaimed once upon a time of the leaders of Eastern Europe, or of today Fidel. The speaker was OAS ambassador Valero who has been doing its best to try to brain wash his colleagues at the OAS. Well, at least we know that his own brain has been quite washed out.
Then the stage moved on to Los Proceres, our monumental avenue built by our one before last dictator, Perez Jimenez, for military parades. Our wanna-be dictator seems to find the setting to his liking. The Army paraded today under posters that were rather political, calling for the union between the army and its people. The media was not allowed to cover the parade and we had to rely on the "cadena" that the official VTV sent us hours and hours. No important sporting event, mercifully as the Euro Cup ended yesterday and the South American one starts tomorrow.
The parade started with the reconstruction of the "batalla de Santa Ines" a rather dubious success of our mid XIX century civil wars. But it has been decided that the name of the battle would be the catch name of the present electoral campaign now that the "comando Ayacucho" floundered so badly during the Recall Election drive. So much for an impartial parade.
As a new development we saw for the first time lots of buses parked along the way, ferrying in a reliable public. Once upon a time whoever wanted to attend the July 5th parade could do so. Now, it seems that times have changed and only the blessed few can attend. An amateur video, by the way, did catch up what seemed to be students of the new Bolivarian University trained as some type of militia and made to take some buses to go to Los Proceres.
The opposition? Well, already eliminated from any National ceremony, it decided not to show up to the National Assembly solemn session. To begin with chavista supporters would have booed them if they had tried to get inside the building. But since the opposition is treated as second class citizenry and barred from any other ceremony, why bother to attend the session?
And so it goes in Venezuela where Chavez preaches suddenly a language of love and reconciliation but were the crude facts everyday contradict his discourse. Do the foreign media see these things? I think that the diplomatic corps is not fooled but sometimes I wonder about the other guys at CNN and BBC...
Monday, July 05, 2004
THE POLLSTER'S WAR IN VENEZUELA: FAKE OR REAL?
Sunday 4, July 2004 (1)
What might have been the main news this week in Caracas was the publication of the partial results of the Greenberg et al. poll, that came flat out to contradict earlier polls from Datanalisis and Consultores 21. Of course this provoked some consternation within the opposition and felicity in chavismo. But was that significant? My answer is no, I am not worried at all and I will explain why at the end.
Chavez and pollsters
Like any government in trouble, the Chavez administration is discrediting any polling organization that does not publish favorable results. Par for the course, even though Datanalisis and Consultores 21 predicted very accurately Chavez victory in 1998. If we had to this that we have an administration that has long stopped accounting for its actions, that runs on emotional arguments, and a president that excoriates the local press and has not given a press conference in 2 years, one should not be surprised at the virulence presented by some notorious chavistas as to adverse polling results. (2)
The pollsters in Venezuela
There are many polling institutes in Venezuela, from the long established ones to hacks that appear at election time. There also the foreign pollsters, serious or not, that are hired on occasion. The recent example that occupies the attention of today's post is the one from Greenberg and associates from the US, that goes against the grain of local recent polls. Unfortunately, this poll complete results and methodology have not been released yet.
The polling difficulties in Venezuela
Polling in Venezuela is rather difficult. The neat split into 5 social sectors actually illustrates quite well the problem. Sectors A, B and C represent the rich, upper middle class and middle class. D and E represent workers and poor. Or so it was in the 80ies when the system was set. But now with nearly 20% official jobless rate and perhaps 50% in the informal economy these divisions are becoming meaningless. Sector A is statistically nonexistent and more and more A and B are considered as one. E, the pauper sector includes probably quite a large number of people near indigent status. In addition the E sector resides in the extensive Caracas and other cities slums and includes those that traditionally have been unwilling or unable to follow the political discourse of the country. The difficulty to poll in a meaningful way this sector should be obvious. The D sector includes more and more the fraction of the C sector that lost its economic stability but not necessarily its values and political motivations. The social changes that have happened in Venezuela in the last 10 years should bring into question some of the polling methods used in the past. Not to mention that recent political pressure could affect even further how people tend to reply to pollster questions. (3)
Recent polls
This is a little survey of recent polls and comments (4)
The least that one can say on these polls, done relatively close in time, is that there is quite a variation. If the results of Indaga and Datos are to be expected, the ones from Greenberg are surprising. These are a considerable reversal of the type of numbers that they used to show. What is more worrisome is that as of today the method has not been published so one cannot decide as to the validity of these numbers. Certainly if they are right today one would wonder about the previous Greenberg surveys when the opposition had much more favorable numbers. Why such a sudden change in such a short period of time? In particular when the "traditional" Venezuelan pollsters agree on the opposition advance even if all agree that this one has shrunk some in recent weeks.
My take
Behavior of the Venezuelan electorate
As Val pointed recently, or Alek Boyd, we are victims of 50 years of populist administrations. A large fraction of the electorate is driven by what they are expecting to get, directly, from whomever is in office, or wants to get into office. This is our curse, perhaps 70% of the electorate motivated by "what is in there for me?", materialistically speaking.
Another often lobbed criticism to the Venezuelan electorate is its short term memory. Indeed, we have reelected in 1988 the president that started corruption big time in Venezuela, Carlos Andres Perez. We have reelected in 1993 the president that has lusted more for power, that has been more willing to make any deal to stay in office, one of them being the "sharing" of the judicial power, Rafael Caldera.
The arguments of the opposition
Well, they are as valid today as they were in April, even more so when one is watching with a certain impotence while the High Court is being packed, or how the oil revenue is spent without any accounting, likely in individual pockets. However there is one that might be backfiring, provisionally, for the opposition: Chavez the dictator. By accepting to go for a Recall Election in spite of all the tricks used to block the signature gathering process, a few in Venezuela wonder if the opposition was not exaggerating all along. It was not, all the other symptoms of an authoritarian wanna-be are there. But people tend to forget and that has saved more than one politician in Venezuela.
The other thing is that the opposition will have a tough job to go against some popular social programs, the ones from the "misiones". Amazingly this time Chavez has managed to strike a chord in the electorate, even if the programs do not reach as many as he would like us to believe, even if they are a den of corruption, even if they are funded at the expense of existing programs and institutions. In fact the present programs have helped erase the memory of previous failures of the social agenda such a the "Plan Bolivar 2000" who ended up enriching a few generals. Indeed, why should Juan Bimba, our Joe Sixpack, care about the packing of the High Court when he might be on the verge of getting a direct hand out? After all justice never reached him but 100 dollars would come in handy.
The opposition dilemma is to expose the cheapness and inadequacy of the present "misiones" while at the same time stating that they will strengthen them, thus indirectly validating them.
So, what are the numbers?
Well, I still think that my detailed table of a few days ago is still valid. I would just add that Chavez has been able to add, albeit temporarily, the few points that are up for grab. He benefits from the positive effect of gaining back some democratic shade, of playing nice, from the "misiones" where he is pouring money while accusing the opposition to threaten to take them away. He also benefits from the down time of the opposition, enjoying his May success and gearing up for totally new type of campaign. Chavez had started his campaign even before the signatures were in and that helps in polls. The reader will remember that I have always given Chavez at least a 30% hard core vote, and if he reaches today a 35-40 % that would give him, a slight edge over the opposition once abstention is factored in.
But this week end is the official start of the campaign. Let's see what happens in the polls after 5 weeks of reminding people the failures of Chavez and why they had to go and sign up. Let's see what happens when Chavez blows up again and starts abusing "cadenas" again.
And in case the reader still doubts, why would a government that genuinely thing that it will win dismiss polls, hire hack pollsters, pack the High Court, set up all sort of electoral tricks, distribute shoddy ID to register questionable voters, suddenly reverse a whole series of policies to try to gain back a sector of the middle class (defense of private property against squatters, new business credits, etc...), and more? Is this is the winner spirit may heaven protect us from the loser spirit!
--------------------------------
(1) I did come across some additional information and edited this post slightly today, July 5, instead of writing an additional one. The information that I found change in nothing my conclusions, but it should be reported so as to provide all the information the readers of this blog need to make up her/his mind.
(2) Since 2001 Chavez has basically stopped giving real press interviews or real press conferences in Venezuela. He only gives them to foreign media and on occasion a tidbit to a particular Venezuelan journalist or a declaration between two doors when he is caught by a journalist. Basically the only messages that the country gets from its president are the "cadenas" and "Alo Presidente" where he rants at will with no one able to question him or even ask for more details.
(3) Thanks to Steven for pointing to me through Haloscan that sanctioning those who signed could have become quite a factor in the results of polling questionnaires. Pollsters might have ways to go around this problem, but I personally think that they have not quite solved this.
(4) Numbers from El Nacional Sunday edition (courtesy of Jose Mora Blog for those who want to read the whole article in Spanish) or from El Universal through the week. Pollsters do not publish numbers in general as these are property of their clients. The comments are mine.
(5) Venezuelanalysis rushes in with a second article to take advantage of these recent polls. Some of the data I publish here is put in nice graphs there. However, interestingly they do not elaborate much on the regional poll of Mercanalisis, which is probably the most solid of the whole lot! Oh well...
Sunday 4, July 2004 (1)
What might have been the main news this week in Caracas was the publication of the partial results of the Greenberg et al. poll, that came flat out to contradict earlier polls from Datanalisis and Consultores 21. Of course this provoked some consternation within the opposition and felicity in chavismo. But was that significant? My answer is no, I am not worried at all and I will explain why at the end.
Chavez and pollsters
Like any government in trouble, the Chavez administration is discrediting any polling organization that does not publish favorable results. Par for the course, even though Datanalisis and Consultores 21 predicted very accurately Chavez victory in 1998. If we had to this that we have an administration that has long stopped accounting for its actions, that runs on emotional arguments, and a president that excoriates the local press and has not given a press conference in 2 years, one should not be surprised at the virulence presented by some notorious chavistas as to adverse polling results. (2)
The pollsters in Venezuela
There are many polling institutes in Venezuela, from the long established ones to hacks that appear at election time. There also the foreign pollsters, serious or not, that are hired on occasion. The recent example that occupies the attention of today's post is the one from Greenberg and associates from the US, that goes against the grain of local recent polls. Unfortunately, this poll complete results and methodology have not been released yet.
The polling difficulties in Venezuela
Polling in Venezuela is rather difficult. The neat split into 5 social sectors actually illustrates quite well the problem. Sectors A, B and C represent the rich, upper middle class and middle class. D and E represent workers and poor. Or so it was in the 80ies when the system was set. But now with nearly 20% official jobless rate and perhaps 50% in the informal economy these divisions are becoming meaningless. Sector A is statistically nonexistent and more and more A and B are considered as one. E, the pauper sector includes probably quite a large number of people near indigent status. In addition the E sector resides in the extensive Caracas and other cities slums and includes those that traditionally have been unwilling or unable to follow the political discourse of the country. The difficulty to poll in a meaningful way this sector should be obvious. The D sector includes more and more the fraction of the C sector that lost its economic stability but not necessarily its values and political motivations. The social changes that have happened in Venezuela in the last 10 years should bring into question some of the polling methods used in the past. Not to mention that recent political pressure could affect even further how people tend to reply to pollster questions. (3)
Recent polls
This is a little survey of recent polls and comments (4)
| Pollster | |||
| Datanalisis | 57.4 | 42.6 | Well established Venezuelan Pollsters. Have been describing a tightening of the race but still give the greater advantage to the opposition. They regularly poll the Venezuelan situation. |
| Consultores 21 | 65.8 | 32.7 | |
| Mercanalisis | 48-63 | 21-36 | Asks what people think will happen, not what they will vote. Divided by regions. Also a long established poll firm. |
| Greenberg, Quinlan, Rosner Research | 44 | 49 | A reputed US polling firm hired on occasion. Has rather suddenly and largely reversed its general trend. Until 2 months ago it gave a large advantage to the opposition. All data and method not released yet |
| Datos | 35 | 51 | No web info, no methodology, except for a Venpres report |
| Indaga and North American Opinion research | 42 | 55 | Indaga is a recent creation from a faculty at the University of Zulia. Both are hired by the current administration. No information available on the other company though there is an extensive discussion on Venezuelanalysis, without giving information on NOAR (5) |
The least that one can say on these polls, done relatively close in time, is that there is quite a variation. If the results of Indaga and Datos are to be expected, the ones from Greenberg are surprising. These are a considerable reversal of the type of numbers that they used to show. What is more worrisome is that as of today the method has not been published so one cannot decide as to the validity of these numbers. Certainly if they are right today one would wonder about the previous Greenberg surveys when the opposition had much more favorable numbers. Why such a sudden change in such a short period of time? In particular when the "traditional" Venezuelan pollsters agree on the opposition advance even if all agree that this one has shrunk some in recent weeks.
My take
Behavior of the Venezuelan electorate
As Val pointed recently, or Alek Boyd, we are victims of 50 years of populist administrations. A large fraction of the electorate is driven by what they are expecting to get, directly, from whomever is in office, or wants to get into office. This is our curse, perhaps 70% of the electorate motivated by "what is in there for me?", materialistically speaking.
Another often lobbed criticism to the Venezuelan electorate is its short term memory. Indeed, we have reelected in 1988 the president that started corruption big time in Venezuela, Carlos Andres Perez. We have reelected in 1993 the president that has lusted more for power, that has been more willing to make any deal to stay in office, one of them being the "sharing" of the judicial power, Rafael Caldera.
The arguments of the opposition
Well, they are as valid today as they were in April, even more so when one is watching with a certain impotence while the High Court is being packed, or how the oil revenue is spent without any accounting, likely in individual pockets. However there is one that might be backfiring, provisionally, for the opposition: Chavez the dictator. By accepting to go for a Recall Election in spite of all the tricks used to block the signature gathering process, a few in Venezuela wonder if the opposition was not exaggerating all along. It was not, all the other symptoms of an authoritarian wanna-be are there. But people tend to forget and that has saved more than one politician in Venezuela.
The other thing is that the opposition will have a tough job to go against some popular social programs, the ones from the "misiones". Amazingly this time Chavez has managed to strike a chord in the electorate, even if the programs do not reach as many as he would like us to believe, even if they are a den of corruption, even if they are funded at the expense of existing programs and institutions. In fact the present programs have helped erase the memory of previous failures of the social agenda such a the "Plan Bolivar 2000" who ended up enriching a few generals. Indeed, why should Juan Bimba, our Joe Sixpack, care about the packing of the High Court when he might be on the verge of getting a direct hand out? After all justice never reached him but 100 dollars would come in handy.
The opposition dilemma is to expose the cheapness and inadequacy of the present "misiones" while at the same time stating that they will strengthen them, thus indirectly validating them.
So, what are the numbers?
Well, I still think that my detailed table of a few days ago is still valid. I would just add that Chavez has been able to add, albeit temporarily, the few points that are up for grab. He benefits from the positive effect of gaining back some democratic shade, of playing nice, from the "misiones" where he is pouring money while accusing the opposition to threaten to take them away. He also benefits from the down time of the opposition, enjoying his May success and gearing up for totally new type of campaign. Chavez had started his campaign even before the signatures were in and that helps in polls. The reader will remember that I have always given Chavez at least a 30% hard core vote, and if he reaches today a 35-40 % that would give him, a slight edge over the opposition once abstention is factored in.
But this week end is the official start of the campaign. Let's see what happens in the polls after 5 weeks of reminding people the failures of Chavez and why they had to go and sign up. Let's see what happens when Chavez blows up again and starts abusing "cadenas" again.
And in case the reader still doubts, why would a government that genuinely thing that it will win dismiss polls, hire hack pollsters, pack the High Court, set up all sort of electoral tricks, distribute shoddy ID to register questionable voters, suddenly reverse a whole series of policies to try to gain back a sector of the middle class (defense of private property against squatters, new business credits, etc...), and more? Is this is the winner spirit may heaven protect us from the loser spirit!
--------------------------------
(1) I did come across some additional information and edited this post slightly today, July 5, instead of writing an additional one. The information that I found change in nothing my conclusions, but it should be reported so as to provide all the information the readers of this blog need to make up her/his mind.
(2) Since 2001 Chavez has basically stopped giving real press interviews or real press conferences in Venezuela. He only gives them to foreign media and on occasion a tidbit to a particular Venezuelan journalist or a declaration between two doors when he is caught by a journalist. Basically the only messages that the country gets from its president are the "cadenas" and "Alo Presidente" where he rants at will with no one able to question him or even ask for more details.
(3) Thanks to Steven for pointing to me through Haloscan that sanctioning those who signed could have become quite a factor in the results of polling questionnaires. Pollsters might have ways to go around this problem, but I personally think that they have not quite solved this.
(4) Numbers from El Nacional Sunday edition (courtesy of Jose Mora Blog for those who want to read the whole article in Spanish) or from El Universal through the week. Pollsters do not publish numbers in general as these are property of their clients. The comments are mine.
(5) Venezuelanalysis rushes in with a second article to take advantage of these recent polls. Some of the data I publish here is put in nice graphs there. However, interestingly they do not elaborate much on the regional poll of Mercanalisis, which is probably the most solid of the whole lot! Oh well...
Friday, July 02, 2004
The last weeks of the chavista regime?
THE LAST WEEKS OF THE CHAVISTA REGIME?
PART 2: Corruption and plunder
Fin de Règne Caracas: a scramble for jobs, caught squatters, corruption accusations flying and the pillaging of PDVSA and our national cultural heritage
In the past couple of weeks came to the forefront a bevy of chavista infighting. It is turning ugly as all sorts of accusations are flying.
Upheaval in squatter deals
One rather amusing case is the arrest of a certain Yasmin Manuit. This very well armed woman was directing one of the gangs that has specialized in squatting all sorts of buildings in the Caracas area under the rule of mayor Freddy Bernal, an erstwhile Chavez faithful. Until now it has seemed that this squatting for profit was done by Lina Ron and Ms. Manuitt, while Bernal had his police turn a blank eye. Suddenly it was all over. Yasmin has seen herself handcuffed and after 4 years of neglect Bernal's police is suddenly expelling squatters. For the last few days Lina, Freddy and Yasmin have been calling each other names, real bad names, not what they were used to do when they discretely blackmailed the building owners that wanted their property back. Who knows what happened there! Someone got short changed? Electoral fever pushing Bernal to pay lip service to private property? Whatever it is, it surely beats Venezuelan soap operas vivid imagination!
Representative Rondon gets even
On a definitely more serious note we have the case of representative Rondon. Until a few days ago the chairman of the powerful oil committee in the National Assembly, he has been fired and expelled from his party for demanding that the oil minister come to the committee to account for his actions. Revolutionary ministers apparently feel that they are exempt of such decadent democratic procedures.
Tonight Rondon has aimed higher in his corruption accusations, targeting Baduel, the general who most helped Chavez on April 2002 and who is expected to be the fourth general in Venezuelan history to get three stars (Chavez has named 3 of them, incidentally, for revolutionary battles one imagines).

In the picture Rondon is shown with what he claims is the original of a 1999 letter that Baduel sent to help secure some contract in the oil industry. Traffic of influences it is called. What is rather amusing is that this was the retort to a weak attempt by representative Luis Tascon to pin down Rondon with the same charge yesterday. Rondon has declared that "he knows things that could make the government fall". I wonder how do they feel using among themselves the questionable tactics that they have used on the opposition for the past 4 years.
The opposition is not running into the arms of Rondon, by the way. After all he has been for quite a while a chavista lap dog and his credibility is barely any better than Tascon of the infamous web page that listed people who signed in the Recall Election drives. His famous "Tascon list" was blatantly used to fire people in the public administration.
One wonders if Rondon has had enough or if he is just upset because he was left out of some juicy deal. However, what I have observed is the amazingly articulate discourse of Rondon, intelligent and organized. Rondon until a few weeks ago was only too happy to repeat the party line in his talk show apparitions. Who is the real Rondon? Is he a free agent or is he making up something, maybe with he anti Baduel camp?
PDVSA is sinking and whatever can be scavenged by chavismo is grabbed
But Rondon accusations are unfortunately not unfounded. Reports of PDVSA troubles are more and more insistent. Gustavo Coronel summarizes all the recent reports from low production to financial maneuvers. Indeed among the many things that PDVSA is doing one is to finance the glorious bolivarian revolution. This has obviously created some "financial problems" not to mention expenses difficult to justify. The solution seems to be quite simple: PDVSA is buying back its bonds to get out of the market and thus avoid the obligation of accounting for its finances to the US Securities and Exchanges Commission.
The problems at PDVSA since its take over by the chavista hacks are for all to see. El Universal translates in English an article justly titled PDVSA: a ship adrift. A rudderless PDVSA, who had become the only reliable financial source of any Venezuelan administration, is looking more and more as the near dead goose of the golden egg. Which did not stop the current pillaging administration to grab an extra 2 billion dollars out of PDVSA coffers to finance the Chavez campaign to try to defeat the Recall Election. Well, more likely to line up the pockets of a few officials that feel that the future comes on August 15, and want to be ready no matter what.
But PDVSA is not the only thing being plundered. In another stunning article Milagros Socorro wrote Thursday in El Nacional about all the Venezuelan historical collections which seem to be disappearing, on how some historical sites are barred from view to the public and the press. As a challenge she has asked for proofs of misdeeds with our cultural treasures or to be left in the places, catalog in hand, to write publicly that all is there and it was just a nasty campaign against the Chavez administration. I am afraid that she will rather be disappointed.
Fin de Règne?
Indeed, one can wonder what will be left of the country after August 15. The feeling that we are the end of something suffuses more and more the air we breathe, the news we watch. Even if Chavez remains a new era will come, an era where Chavez will finally control all and democracy as we have known it since 1958 will be gone. It will be a pauperized country, a country unable to reach the growth level it requires to have a chance of leaving poverty. A country on the way to a modern Cuban lifestyle, or on its way to civil war. Opposition and chavismo all know that. This explains the atmosphere we have now where all seem to wait for the sky to fall while a few try to make a last quick buck. Though, no matter the perturbing recent polls, some like this blogger hope for blue skies. There were always people putting their hopes on the new king.
PART 2: Corruption and plunder
Fin de Règne Caracas: a scramble for jobs, caught squatters, corruption accusations flying and the pillaging of PDVSA and our national cultural heritage
In the past couple of weeks came to the forefront a bevy of chavista infighting. It is turning ugly as all sorts of accusations are flying.
Upheaval in squatter deals
One rather amusing case is the arrest of a certain Yasmin Manuit. This very well armed woman was directing one of the gangs that has specialized in squatting all sorts of buildings in the Caracas area under the rule of mayor Freddy Bernal, an erstwhile Chavez faithful. Until now it has seemed that this squatting for profit was done by Lina Ron and Ms. Manuitt, while Bernal had his police turn a blank eye. Suddenly it was all over. Yasmin has seen herself handcuffed and after 4 years of neglect Bernal's police is suddenly expelling squatters. For the last few days Lina, Freddy and Yasmin have been calling each other names, real bad names, not what they were used to do when they discretely blackmailed the building owners that wanted their property back. Who knows what happened there! Someone got short changed? Electoral fever pushing Bernal to pay lip service to private property? Whatever it is, it surely beats Venezuelan soap operas vivid imagination!
Representative Rondon gets even
On a definitely more serious note we have the case of representative Rondon. Until a few days ago the chairman of the powerful oil committee in the National Assembly, he has been fired and expelled from his party for demanding that the oil minister come to the committee to account for his actions. Revolutionary ministers apparently feel that they are exempt of such decadent democratic procedures.
Tonight Rondon has aimed higher in his corruption accusations, targeting Baduel, the general who most helped Chavez on April 2002 and who is expected to be the fourth general in Venezuelan history to get three stars (Chavez has named 3 of them, incidentally, for revolutionary battles one imagines).
In the picture Rondon is shown with what he claims is the original of a 1999 letter that Baduel sent to help secure some contract in the oil industry. Traffic of influences it is called. What is rather amusing is that this was the retort to a weak attempt by representative Luis Tascon to pin down Rondon with the same charge yesterday. Rondon has declared that "he knows things that could make the government fall". I wonder how do they feel using among themselves the questionable tactics that they have used on the opposition for the past 4 years.
The opposition is not running into the arms of Rondon, by the way. After all he has been for quite a while a chavista lap dog and his credibility is barely any better than Tascon of the infamous web page that listed people who signed in the Recall Election drives. His famous "Tascon list" was blatantly used to fire people in the public administration.
One wonders if Rondon has had enough or if he is just upset because he was left out of some juicy deal. However, what I have observed is the amazingly articulate discourse of Rondon, intelligent and organized. Rondon until a few weeks ago was only too happy to repeat the party line in his talk show apparitions. Who is the real Rondon? Is he a free agent or is he making up something, maybe with he anti Baduel camp?
PDVSA is sinking and whatever can be scavenged by chavismo is grabbed
But Rondon accusations are unfortunately not unfounded. Reports of PDVSA troubles are more and more insistent. Gustavo Coronel summarizes all the recent reports from low production to financial maneuvers. Indeed among the many things that PDVSA is doing one is to finance the glorious bolivarian revolution. This has obviously created some "financial problems" not to mention expenses difficult to justify. The solution seems to be quite simple: PDVSA is buying back its bonds to get out of the market and thus avoid the obligation of accounting for its finances to the US Securities and Exchanges Commission.
The problems at PDVSA since its take over by the chavista hacks are for all to see. El Universal translates in English an article justly titled PDVSA: a ship adrift. A rudderless PDVSA, who had become the only reliable financial source of any Venezuelan administration, is looking more and more as the near dead goose of the golden egg. Which did not stop the current pillaging administration to grab an extra 2 billion dollars out of PDVSA coffers to finance the Chavez campaign to try to defeat the Recall Election. Well, more likely to line up the pockets of a few officials that feel that the future comes on August 15, and want to be ready no matter what.
But PDVSA is not the only thing being plundered. In another stunning article Milagros Socorro wrote Thursday in El Nacional about all the Venezuelan historical collections which seem to be disappearing, on how some historical sites are barred from view to the public and the press. As a challenge she has asked for proofs of misdeeds with our cultural treasures or to be left in the places, catalog in hand, to write publicly that all is there and it was just a nasty campaign against the Chavez administration. I am afraid that she will rather be disappointed.
Fin de Règne?
Indeed, one can wonder what will be left of the country after August 15. The feeling that we are the end of something suffuses more and more the air we breathe, the news we watch. Even if Chavez remains a new era will come, an era where Chavez will finally control all and democracy as we have known it since 1958 will be gone. It will be a pauperized country, a country unable to reach the growth level it requires to have a chance of leaving poverty. A country on the way to a modern Cuban lifestyle, or on its way to civil war. Opposition and chavismo all know that. This explains the atmosphere we have now where all seem to wait for the sky to fall while a few try to make a last quick buck. Though, no matter the perturbing recent polls, some like this blogger hope for blue skies. There were always people putting their hopes on the new king.
THE LAST WEEKS OF THE CHAVISTA REGIME?
PART 1: I wanna be a Justice!
Fin de Règne Caracas: a scramble for jobs, caught squatters, corruption accusations flying and the pillaging of PDVSA and our national cultural heritage
Is this an optimist title? Well, yes in that this is what I personally hope. Unfortunately it is still far from certain. But the atmosphere that is in Caracas these days is more evocative of the end of an era than the promise of a bright new future. For all of its claims of an impending victory, the chavista ship looks more like a Titanic that hit an iceberg of 2.6 million signatures.
I was on the road these last days and could not write. Then again I would have had trouble choosing a particular issue. Thus, as I do on occasion I will pick a few representative scenes that do evoke this deliciously deliquescent Fin de Règne atmosphere that the French qualified so well, having had so many kings which such endless reigns. Next, all from a judicial scramble to a corruption accusation to the chief of staff general Baduel. A rather long catalog, but it must be told.
The judicial sauve qui peut
Now that the new law of the High Court has been approved (at the very least questionably) it is time to fire the Justices that are not in the good graces of the regime. But surprisingly it has become more important to name the extra dozen or so Justices that the administration can now place in the court. As the Recall Election nears, a 12 year term seat in the high court seems quite appetizing for some, just in case.
Already the formation of the committee to chose the new Justices was not very promising. The opposition considering the whole deal illegal decided not participate and prepares instead for the mother of all filibusters. However, the worst was the election of the chairman of the committee: Representative Carreño. If there is a discredited representative in the Venezuelan parliament it is Carreño. From announcing the death of a very alive Montesinos (1) to declaring that Direct TV had a hidden camera in the decoding device to spy the Venezuelan people, this representative has demonstrated once and again that he is totally unfit for any public office. But as one of the very few unconditional of El Supremo it is certain that he will do all the necessary dirty work to ensure that all new Justices tow closely the Revolutionary line.
The list of judicial nominees so far goes beyond all that one would have expected in cynical posturing. One is representative Luis Velásquez Alvaray, the father of the beast, the new Judicial Law and a pro Chavez hack if any. Well, he sent a letter to the manager of the president's party to say that as of now he will not be exercising any political function for the party. The letter received and signed by the manager was then duly registered at the notary public. Today Velásquez Alvaray announced that he was candidate to the High Court and that as registered in the notary he was now impartial and thus fit for the job, to offer justice to all.
For the US readers. Imagine a few years ago that Edward Kennedy or Jesse Helms would want to be named to the Supreme Court and would sign a personal note as to their impartiality and fairness as to that moment. And try to imagine that Republicans or Democrats would buy that one and vote for their nomination. Yes, that gross! Except that Helms and Kennedy would have the good sense not to expose themselves to such ridicule, and actually took pride in their partisanship which actually reminded their respective parties of their core values.
But it gets better. Among the list of unfit candidates appears the actual formal head of the Electoral Board, CNE's Carrasquero! That is, the guy supervising, in theory, the critical electoral moment is bailing out to the High Court! And gossip has that he wants nothing less but to become the new president of the High Court as a prize from having being able to postpone by a full year the Recall Election. Just as if the head of the US GOP electoral effort suddenly decided to fill an unexpected Supreme Court opening. Unbelievable nerve!
What a way to save one's butt in case an unfavorable electoral outcome were to happen: sauve qui peut! (whoever can save his skin, do it!, a lousy translation)
But you do not need to wait for the installation of the new High Court to have a taste of how justice will be administered in Venezuela. The investigation report by the National Assembly on the burnt soldiers of Fort Mara stated that the violent fire was originated from inside! From soldiers that at most had matches! Of course the opposition did not approve the report. And the majority representatives that voted yeah are the same ones that will vote on the designation of the new judges.
Thus Human Rights Watch stands vindicated as his report last month is proving to be quite to the point. HRW even allows itself to reply to the rudeness of the Vice President when it disqualified them in a demonstration of his ignorance and political vindictiveness. Which of course does not stop other lackeys from barking against HRW.
Justice and self criticism are the first casualties of the end of eras.
PART 1: I wanna be a Justice!
Fin de Règne Caracas: a scramble for jobs, caught squatters, corruption accusations flying and the pillaging of PDVSA and our national cultural heritage
Is this an optimist title? Well, yes in that this is what I personally hope. Unfortunately it is still far from certain. But the atmosphere that is in Caracas these days is more evocative of the end of an era than the promise of a bright new future. For all of its claims of an impending victory, the chavista ship looks more like a Titanic that hit an iceberg of 2.6 million signatures.
I was on the road these last days and could not write. Then again I would have had trouble choosing a particular issue. Thus, as I do on occasion I will pick a few representative scenes that do evoke this deliciously deliquescent Fin de Règne atmosphere that the French qualified so well, having had so many kings which such endless reigns. Next, all from a judicial scramble to a corruption accusation to the chief of staff general Baduel. A rather long catalog, but it must be told.
The judicial sauve qui peut
Now that the new law of the High Court has been approved (at the very least questionably) it is time to fire the Justices that are not in the good graces of the regime. But surprisingly it has become more important to name the extra dozen or so Justices that the administration can now place in the court. As the Recall Election nears, a 12 year term seat in the high court seems quite appetizing for some, just in case.
Already the formation of the committee to chose the new Justices was not very promising. The opposition considering the whole deal illegal decided not participate and prepares instead for the mother of all filibusters. However, the worst was the election of the chairman of the committee: Representative Carreño. If there is a discredited representative in the Venezuelan parliament it is Carreño. From announcing the death of a very alive Montesinos (1) to declaring that Direct TV had a hidden camera in the decoding device to spy the Venezuelan people, this representative has demonstrated once and again that he is totally unfit for any public office. But as one of the very few unconditional of El Supremo it is certain that he will do all the necessary dirty work to ensure that all new Justices tow closely the Revolutionary line.
The list of judicial nominees so far goes beyond all that one would have expected in cynical posturing. One is representative Luis Velásquez Alvaray, the father of the beast, the new Judicial Law and a pro Chavez hack if any. Well, he sent a letter to the manager of the president's party to say that as of now he will not be exercising any political function for the party. The letter received and signed by the manager was then duly registered at the notary public. Today Velásquez Alvaray announced that he was candidate to the High Court and that as registered in the notary he was now impartial and thus fit for the job, to offer justice to all.
For the US readers. Imagine a few years ago that Edward Kennedy or Jesse Helms would want to be named to the Supreme Court and would sign a personal note as to their impartiality and fairness as to that moment. And try to imagine that Republicans or Democrats would buy that one and vote for their nomination. Yes, that gross! Except that Helms and Kennedy would have the good sense not to expose themselves to such ridicule, and actually took pride in their partisanship which actually reminded their respective parties of their core values.
But it gets better. Among the list of unfit candidates appears the actual formal head of the Electoral Board, CNE's Carrasquero! That is, the guy supervising, in theory, the critical electoral moment is bailing out to the High Court! And gossip has that he wants nothing less but to become the new president of the High Court as a prize from having being able to postpone by a full year the Recall Election. Just as if the head of the US GOP electoral effort suddenly decided to fill an unexpected Supreme Court opening. Unbelievable nerve!
What a way to save one's butt in case an unfavorable electoral outcome were to happen: sauve qui peut! (whoever can save his skin, do it!, a lousy translation)
But you do not need to wait for the installation of the new High Court to have a taste of how justice will be administered in Venezuela. The investigation report by the National Assembly on the burnt soldiers of Fort Mara stated that the violent fire was originated from inside! From soldiers that at most had matches! Of course the opposition did not approve the report. And the majority representatives that voted yeah are the same ones that will vote on the designation of the new judges.
Thus Human Rights Watch stands vindicated as his report last month is proving to be quite to the point. HRW even allows itself to reply to the rudeness of the Vice President when it disqualified them in a demonstration of his ignorance and political vindictiveness. Which of course does not stop other lackeys from barking against HRW.
Justice and self criticism are the first casualties of the end of eras.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)