Tuesday, May 15, 2018

The Venezuelan opposition: what went wrong?

About one year ago in between tear gasses outings I thought that maybe the Maduro dictatorship was in its last throes, that the opposition in Venezuela was going to prevail. Today Maduro is coasting to reelection, fraud and all, with only the meekest of protest at home, around lack of food and medicine. The louder protest comes from overseas.

How can one explain such a stupendous change of fortunes? Hint: it is not due only to military repression.
The opposition has failed to harness its momentum.

There are two basic reasons: a failure of diagnostic and a rivalry amongst its leadership, each one selling the bear hide before killing it.

The diagnostic

The opposition had been too tardy in calling the narco regime of Maduro a dictatorship even though all elements were there to make the accurate diagnostic. And when finally enough within the opposition became willing to call a spade a spade, then there still were enough inside the opposition to sabotage the processus.

I do not know what the opposition could have or should have done if the accurate diagnostic had been taken long ago. But one sure thing that any recently graduated doctor will tell you is that as long as you do not have a diagnostic, there is no sure treatment to deal with the sickness.

I will address some of the baltant failures of the opposition below, but the fact that there is no "diagnostic" inside the opposition can be seen with the dismal failure of the Frente Amplio, a movement created after the opposition umbrella organization MUD failed so miserably in replying to the regime electoral fraud in the later half of 2017.

One of the first things the Frente Amplio did was to announce neighborhood meetings to check out on what was ailing the population and its needs. Really? After 20 years and you still need to inquire about what is wrong in Venezuela? I lost interest right then and there. But I do observe that the Frente Amplio has been unable to deal with the division of the opposition when Henri Falcon decided to throw his electoral hat in the ring.  Of all the opposition failures at coalescing into something strong, the Frente Amplio was the one that crashed the fastest.

Prime donne

The other major failing of the opposition has been to come up with a credible voice. The rivalry between its leaders eventually led them to commit fatal mistakes, and broke the victory points of early 2017.

I will accuse Henri Ramos Allup as the first guilty party. His intempestive decision to participate in the October governor elections without real consultation, without preparing for them long in advance has led to a general demobilization of the opposition electorate which has collapsed the MUD electorate (and the Frente Amplio of course as nobody bothered).

But he is not alone. The ambitions of Borges and Capriles did play a role. And of course the early abstention party who have yet to propose a strategy. Their abstention for the sake of it had a pernicious effect and paralyzed the MUD leadership even more than the agressive regime. I have in mind Maria Corina Machado but at least least scored a point yesterday meeting in spectacular staging with the Uribista opposition about to win Colombia's election in a few days.  Click the tweet below to see the border's barriers in cheers.

Clearly someone is looking for the post May 20 situation. The Colombians are clear on several things, one of them is that the opposition leadership needs to change, even if they use Maria Corina as some kind of Trojan horse.  No guarantee of success but this is the first opposition coup in weeks...

Of course the worst saboteur turns out to have been Henri Falcon who pledged to withdraw before election days if the voting conditions did not improve. Well, not only they did not improve but they are actually getting worse in the last stretch with the frontal threats and vote buying of Maduro.  And yet Henri is still there. I can tell you that for example my S.O. and his mother will vote because they are under supervision and we are only debating which one of the token candidates they shall vote for to make sure neither Maduro of Falcon gets it.  Falcon has been so lousy, so unconvincing, that even the opposition that will be dragged into voting will not do it for his ticket, guessing appropriately that one of his secret motives to be crowned as official opposition by the regime.

My take, for what it is worth

We hold a very moderate optimism.  The opposition has finally divided and that is not a bad thing. We can worry about further divisions but now that a more hard core and coherent opposition can form without the ballast of double faced politicians we may finally reach a true diagnostic on the narco regime and perhaps a real strategy to confront it. The disastrous situation awaiting us will help us.

1 comment:

  1. The opposition failed because it's mostly holds a social-democratic ideology that is too coward to break away with socialism once it's installed. There is no "gradual" solution when the whole society got highly addicted to state intervention in all spheres and aspects of life. See how Macri insists on an absurd 15% inflation rate as the acceptable, because it's the path of least resistance. Venezuela needs to go full libertarian, Switzerland or Hong Kong like, any less of that won't neutralize the cancer.


Comments policy:

1) Comments are moderated after the sixth day of publication. It may take up to a day or two for your note to appear then.

2) Your post will appear if you follow the basic rules. I will be ruthless in erasing, as well as those who replied to any off rule comment.

This is an anti Chavez/chavismo blog, Readers have made up their minds long ago. Trying to prove us wrong is considered a troll. Still, you are welcome as a chavista to post if you want to explain us coherently as to why chavismo does this or that. We are still waiting for that to happen.
Insults and put downs are frowned upon and I will be sole judge on whether to publish them.