Sunday, April 25, 2010

Maria Corina wins Baruta as Primero Justicia loses it

The primary results are in, by 10 PM, faster than what the CNE ever gave them, with 98% of the votes counted (we are still waiting for the CNE 2007 final count...).  A quick round up:

  • Participation was low but in the range of what you expect a primary election to be, the more so in the country of the Tascon List (see at the bottom of this blog if you do not know what that is).  In Baruta/Chacao/El-Hatillo district where the opposition votes more than 80% against Chavez with an abstention in the 40%, the participation, factoring out the meager chavista vote was about 25%.  True, chavismo is going to try to paint this as a major failure but who in his right mind thinks that the 75% that did not vote today are going to vote for the chavista candidate in September?  At any rate, it is an argument that chavismo might want to use carefully before it knows the results of its own primary which, rumor has it, will not even count its ballots at the table but at PSUV central, with the candidates having to wait for someone to let them know whether they won....  talk about incentive in voting in running.
  • Participation in Lara seems to have been low, a possible indication that everybody there knows that the real contest is between Falcon and Chavez and that outside of Palavecino district there is no hope for the opposition.
  • It was low for Carabobo but that is mostly due to the decomposition of Proyecto Venezuela leaving people in waiting of the replacement to come.  I venture to say that people are not quite aware yet that primaries is a good way to regenerate the body politic.  The 61% victory of Cocchiola in Valencia, who was undercut in his 2008 mayor bid by the vindictiveness of Proyecto Venezuela is sweet for me and confirms that PVZL is in trouble and had better shape up fast.
  • The projection pie I gave yesterday does not really change as I made it in function of likely seats to be won, regardless of primaries been held.
Conclusion: all in all it went fairly well and thus I am sure that tonight a few within the MUD must regret that they did not include a few more primaries in their original plan.  While a few resurrected fossils are breathing a sight of relief that they did not have to go through a primary.

Let's just think for a moment if instead of 22 jubilant winners we would have been watching tonight about 40.... at least one in every state....

Interesting fact.  Maria Corina Machado won with 50% of the vote.  A clear cut victory, no appeal, from the safest opposition district and the one that voted the most today.  And a serious set back for Primero Justicia who was considering the district as its national bastion.  It will be fascinating to write the story on how Primero Justicia blew away its strength there.  True, that its main contender for the 2008 Baruta mayor was barred from running allowed UNT's Blyde sweep in easily.  But the errors of PJ predate that election and the victory of Machado running as an independent with the support of UNT and AD shows that the ground have shifted decisively against Primero Justicia there.

The first blow was the division of PJ, which resulted in two of its brightest stars, Lopez and Blyde, move to UNT.  Then Leopoldo Lopez did its own movement and managed to retain Chacao mayor away from PJ while Blyde got, in large aprt in luck, Baruta.  Amazingly PJ failed to take El Hatillo where it was the main force in the municipal council.  thus PJ who should normally controlled 4 out of 5 Caracas districts now has only the Petare/Sucre one.

PJ is duly pissed off and one of its boss, Miranda governor Capriles, demands that the  the substitute of Simonovis, one of the political prisoners be elected, probably putting in a PJ guy.  In fact already tonight there was a rumor that Vecchio, runner up of Machado, should be given that choice spot. See, Simonovis is in jail and will not be released even if he wins.  Thus the substitute automatically becomes the representative of Baruta, at least until an amnesty law is enacted.

It seems to me that a certain electoral rapprochement is taking place between Leopoldo Lopez and his former mates of Primero Justicia is taking place.  Today at their voting station my parents were surprised to see Vecchio saying hi! to everyone in line accompanied by PJ Uzcategui......  the sad truth is that since Leopoldo went his way neither him nor PJ have grown as one would have expected to grow, considering the way they grew in the early Chavez years.  UNT might be plodding on its own, but tonight it took a choice plum out of PJ.  With Blyde as mayor and Machado as representative, it is going to be a while until PJ recovers its former heartland.


    1. Daniel

      I believe there was a backlash against PJ as a reaction to their behavior in the MUD and especially against Julio Borgues.
      I personally switched my vote from Carlos Ocariz to Maria Corina only because he belonged to PJ.
      hopefully, they realize that it is time to put the country's interest first, not their own

    2. Anonymous12:47 PM

      Daniel -- thanks for your analysis.

      You're not giving MCM enough credit.

      The vote didn't have anything to do with PJ -- MCM won because people wanted to see her in the Asamblea. She did a (mostly) good job as head of Sumate and she ran a good primary campaign. Many of those who supported her will continue to support PJ and their candidates in other races.

    3. well, what do you know, the same post elicits two opposed views...

      let me repritn a line from this post:

      "It will be fascinating to write the story on how Primero Justicia blew away its strength there. "

      Maybe it was not clear, but my intention was only an executive summary without entering int the details of MCM personal merits and what not.

      However observe that Blyde, the NT mayor was sitting next to MCM during her victory press conference. Telling, no?

      PJ is not done with, by far, as it is penetrating other areas (it should, for example, get one of the Aragua seats). My point was that its original bastion, the Chacao Baruta corridor, is lost, with a surprising ease, for the time being.

      Then again the District voter is probably one of the best informed of Venezuela and is perfectly able to decide its vote on personality instead than party line. Not an excuse for PJ since it should know better and field a stronger candidate than Vecchio ad his laundry list, as commendable as that list was. Read my previous endorsement of MCM to understand what I mean.

    4. Juan Cristobal3:01 PM

      I agree with Anonymous, this vote wasn't about party, it was about personalities. PJ endorsed Vecchio at the last minute, as a negotiating tool in exchange for getting E. Mendoza off their back and getting L. Lopez on bard. Did it work? We don't know. But it's hard to draw a distinction between MCM and PJ, they're all in the same boat. PJ didn't really have a candidate in this primary.

    5. Juan Cristobal

      Ahem... did you rad my comment above in addition to the post?

      I loved your misspelling "Lopez on bard". :) some telling lapsus?

    6. La pegó ganó Maria Corina y espero que todos quedemos unidos

      La Maga Lee


    Comments policy:

    1) Comments are moderated after the fourth day of publication. It may take up to a day or two for your note to appear then.

    2) Your post will appear if you follow the basic rules. I will be ruthless in erasing, as well as those who replied to any off rule comment.

    Do not be repetitive.
    Do not bring grudges and fights from other blogs here (this is the strictest rule).
    This is an anti Chavez/chavismo blog, Readers have made up their minds long ago. Trying to prove us wrong is considered a troll. Still, you are welcome as a chavista to post if you want to explain us coherently as to why chavismo does this or that. We are still waiting for that to happen.
    Insults and put downs are frowned upon and I will be sole judge on whether to publish them.