Wednesday, March 07, 2007

Cien Años de Soledad

This week caught me by surprise learning that it is the 40 th anniversary of the publication of Cien Años de Soledad, and the 80th birthday of his author.

It is easy to go bonkers on what is one of the essential books, One Hundred Years of Solitude. Yet the first time I tried to read it I did not like it much, I did not even finish it. These days I was in high school, molded in the Cartesian way while Zola was making slowly a socialist of me. Socialist in the good sense, not the XXI century hogwash which is refried communism cum militarism. Reading the definitely non Cartesian work of Garcia Marquez was not my cup of tea then.

Years went by. Once at home over some holiday I found the unfinished book. The same edition, by the way, on Garcia Marquez head. Then I had the strange ability, and vice I suppose, of being able to read more than one book at once and thus to leave a given book for months or even years. These days, I could just go back to the last read page and keep going on as if nothing, not even reading back a few pages. Today at the end of a newspaper article I catch myself sometimes trying to remember what was at the beginning. After picking up the book again, I got where I had left it, two thirds of the way and I finished it in a single sitting, and then went back to read the start again, though the next day I think.

I have read it twice since, and once in English. The time in English I did not read it completely I must confess, I was just checking out the quality of the translation and I was not impressed, but I still was caught enough, even in English, that I read more than half of it, jumping from highlight to highlight.

And I know that I will read it again, at least once again. It probably will be one luxurious edition, hard back, large print. I will read it sitting on a wooden rocking chair if possible, or laying in a hammock, with the window open, to let the tropical evening breeze in, to hear the deafening rainy season, or smell the dusty dry season. I will read mostly at night, a couple of pages at a time, aloud to myself. I will read it all aloud since I discovered on my last reading that it was better read aloud, like children learning. I always learn in Solitude. It is the Spanish of my childhood, it is the Spanish that took me away from my Cartesian French education and made me a Latin-American.

I have read most books of Garcia Marquez. I think that Love in the Time of Cholera might be his best work. The General in his Labyrinth was perhaps his most interesting for me, how Bolivar shaped us through his legend for better or for worse, even if it is not implicit when you read it. But all of us who know of Bolivar have him on the back of our mind as we read the book.

Saying that Cien Años is my favorite book would be silly: I have read and loved too many books to have a favorite. But One Hundred Years has something that gets to me. It is indeed so rich, one can discover so many new things each time one reads it. But that is not why it hits me. The thing about Cien Años is that it speaks to every moment of one’s life; it changes language as you get older, so it can keep talking to you. It says to us all what we need to know about our countries and our people, and how we change over time. There is probably no better introduction to Venezuela and the Chavez phenomenon than to read One Hundred Years of Solitude and follow it with Chronicle of a Death Foretold. Read these two books carefully, with an open mind, and you will realize that Garcia Marquez has said it all, has invented nothing, and just as Melquiades did in one Hundred Years he wrote his own Chronicle to foretell all what will happen in Latin America. Macondo might be Aracataca, but it is also Choroni, it is Chivacoa, it is Caracas when it was a small town, and it is Miraflores which has become a small town inside Caracas where a group of lunatics explore ideological incest.

But there is also something about Cien Años de Soledad. It has one of the best opening lines of any book I have ever read, as good, if longer, than perhaps the best opening line of all times from the Quijote:
En un lugar de la Mancha, de cuyo nombre no quiero acordarme, no ha mucho tiempo que vivía un hidalgo de los de lanza en astillero, adarga antigua, rocín flaco y galgo corredor.
Even if you have never read the Quijote, as is shamefully my case, you cannot help but think that this opening sentence cannot be matched in any language. Garcia Marquez almost matches it, or matches it in my very humble opinion. It could only have been matched in Spanish I suppose:
Muchos años después, frente al pelotón de fusilamiento, el coronel Aureliano Buendía había de recordar aquella tarde remota en que su padre lo llevó a conocer el hielo. Macondo era entonces una aldea de veinte casas de barro y cañabrava construidas a la orilla de un río de aguas diáfanas que se precipitaban por un lecho de piedras pulidas, blancas y enormes como huevos prehistóricos. El mundo era tan reciente, que muchas cosas carecían de nombre, y para mencionarlas había que señalarlas con el dedo.
I do not know about you, but I am unable to read this without reading it again aloud.

But what is perhaps the most unique feature of this book is the ending. Because Cien Años has a memorable beginning but perhaps an even more memorable ending. I confess that after having read this last paragraph of the book dozens of times, I still get goose bumps each and every time I read it.
Entonces empezó el viento, tibio, incipiente, lleno de voces del pasado, de murmullos de geranios antiguos, de suspiros de desengaños anteriores a las nostalgias más tenaces. No lo advirtió porque en aquel momento estaba descubriendo los primeros indicios de su ser, en un abuelo concupiscente que se dejaba arrastrar por la frivolidad a través de un páramo alucinado, en busca de una mujer hermosa a quien no haría feliz. Aureliano lo reconoció, persiguió los caminos ocultos de su descendencia, y encontró el instante de su propia concepción entre los alacranes y las mariposas amarillas de un baño crepuscular, donde un menestral saciaba su lujuria con una mujer que se le entregaba por rebeldía. Estaba tan absorto, que no sintió tampoco la segunda arremetida del viento, cuya potencia ciclónica arrancó de los quicios las puertas y las ventanas, descuajó el techo de la galería oriental y desarraigó los cimientos. Sólo entonces descubrió que Amaranta Úrsula no era su hermana, sino su tía, y que Francis Drake había asaltado a Riohacha solamente para que ellos pudieran buscarse por los laberintos más intrincados de la sangre, hasta engendrar el animal mitológico que había de poner término a la estirpe. Macondo era ya un pavoroso remolino de polvo y escombros centrifugado por la cólera del huracán bíblico, cuando Aureliano saltó once páginas para no perder el tiempo en hechos demasiado conocidos, y empezó a descifrar el instante que estaba viviendo, descifrándolo a medida que lo vivía, profetizándose a sí mismo en el acto de descifrar la última página de los pergaminos, como si se estuviera viendo en un espejo hablado Entonces dio otro salto para anticiparse a las predicciones y averiguar la fecha y las circunstancias de su muerte. Sin embargo, antes de llegar al verso final ya había comprendido que no saldría jamás de ese cuarto, pues estaba previsto que la ciudad de los espejos (o los espejismos) sería arrasada por el viento y desterrada de la memoria de los hombres en el instante en que Aureliano Babilonia acabara de descifrar los pergaminos, y que todo lo escrito en ellos era irrepetible desde siempre y para siempre porque las estirpes condenadas a cien años de soledad no tenían una segunda oportunidad sobre la tierra.
I cannot think of anything better to write to give homage but to quote one of the most important books in my life.

-The end-

Tuesday, March 06, 2007

Books and stationery bombed in Iraq

Iraq is many things. One is that there is a group of people who are using Iraq troubles to bring it back to a medieval obscurantism, who would like very much the Sharia as the only law and who would love to see women in Burqa, preferably illiterate. If you need to convince yourself of that just look at the latest Baghdad bombing, a totally useless one (as if there were any useful, to begin with, in a civil war). A street which in better days was a literary street, a sort of Harvard Square before the GAP et al. took over, was bombed yesterday. There is one thing about such pseudo revolutionaries who give lip service to the US occupation, when everything is said and done: more important for them is what will Iraq be once it is freed of the US. If Iraq is not going to be according to their mental construct, and mental is used here in all the richness of its meanings, then they probably do not care much about Iraq freedom and they will have no problem destroying everything.

A moral abject lessons for us, to watch against all Taliban like revolutionaries and guerrillas, from Iraq to the FARC, or to the dark lurking extremes that chavismo is slowly nurturing inside and who probably would not mind having a few books and papers and TV stations burnt down.

-The end (of this once in a blue moon stray outside of Venezuela politics, a subject heavy enough by itself)-

How to deal with chavismo: pop some corn, sit down and watch

One of the nice things about being now in a quasi hopeless opposition is that you have more time for yourself. Instead of being tied in knots over the latest Chavez utterance, you can relax some and start watching the funny part of it. After all, like all regimes that control everything, the self destruction starts from within. If you cannot light the fuse you can at least watch who is doing it and see it all happen. These past days we have seen enough to have a great time. Three in no particular order of importance.

Hillary blasts Chavez (hat tip M.)

Well, you know that when even Hillary Clinton is on Chavez case, his US propaganda machine, the infamous VIO, is not working properly. Well, we have known that all along, flattery and constant praise only end up ruining the sycophants that should have known better (à la Weisbrot). I am waiting for the other shoe to drop with Obama and then we will see who the VIO will support for the US campaign. The sad truth for Chavez is that all he sent on US propaganda and US attacks have only served to unite more and more Democrats against him. Remember the very strong statement of Kerry against Chavez? See, if there is one thing I learned in my US years is that the US like to wash their dirty laundry among themselves and really do not like other people bringing in their own skid marked underwear. OR, in other more diplomatic words: the Dems get much better intelligence on Chavez than this one gets on the US.

Uribe to Chavez: thanks!

And while we are discussing foreign intervention. Chavez is fond of accusing that the whole world is after him, mixing nicely his paranoia with his very own sociopath tendencies. As recently as this weekend Rangel now out of office felt compelled to state again that "all were ganging up against Chavez". Rangel knows how to flatter his ex boss to get him to come as the first interview in the TV talk show that Rangel is renewing from his journalistic past. In the Sunday premiere show Chavez went again about all these nasty people, CIA mostly, infiltrating everything in Venezuela and trying to kill him for the nth time.

Well, a very nice tale for those who love Chavez but the fact of the matter is that only too often Chavez gets into trouble because HE IS the one meddling in other people's business. If we all know that Bolivia is now a protectorate of Cubazuela, that does not mean that Chavez is sitting still elsewhere. And he got caught in Colombia this week end.

See, the newly appointed ambassador, Pavel Rondon, has been making the rounds of leftist Polo Democratico meetings around Colombia, with little diplomatic self restraint when it is time to attack Uribe. All very amusing, and probably very, very counterproductive. Uribe is mired into some nasty scandal about some of his supporters cavorting with the paramilitary. Even his foreign minister Araujo had to resign in a rush, even though she used to dance Vallenato with Chavez for the cameras. Now, thanks to this video a new scandal arrives bringing back again the attention on the FARC. Uribe did not miss a beat. His new foreign minister, also named Araujo, and a newly FARC escaped hostage (6 years!) at that, did not mince his words on the ambassador actions. As Alo Ciudadano said "ese si que no baila Vallenato" (this one for sure does not dance Vallenato)

No more unique socialist party in Venezuela?

I was greatly amused this week by the reactions to the last political bureau reunion of PODEMOS. They decided, it seems, that they will take the risk not to join the PUSV, that structure Chavez is creating, a proposed monolithic party that will hoard all public jobs in Venezuela. Minor coalition partners have been given the choice to either join or to forget about sharing in the loot. Even the Communist Party of Venezuela has been told to line up!

So, not unexpectedly, PODEMOS and the PCV and even PPT, who did help to nicely pad up Chavez majority, are not very pleased and are in that Hamletian paradigm where they know that if they do not follow Chavez, well he will dispose of them as he has disposed of any uncomfortable ally in the past. Trust me, it is rather nasty in general. Some, totally gutted of any self respect and inner will have come back crawling like Arias Cardenas. Sad, very sad...

But very amusing. See, PODEMOS who has had no problem balking out the MAS in 2002 to retain its share of riches from Chavez coffers, which has proposed some of the most infamous legislation to strengthen Chavez power is now finding itself in the hot seat. They should have known better, they should have watched around. But human nature immense hubris made them fall into the trap.

It is also very amusing as I watch the very incompetent opposition delight in the apparent PODEMOS break up. Well, the silly Venezuelan desperate side of the opposition is willing to follow yet another white knight out of nowhere. Except that the offered White Knight has an impressive track record of incompetence, treachery, low life quality that makes it rather unqualified to create the new opposition to Chavez. I mean, can anyone seriously think of bloggers like me ever voting for the slime bucket of Ismael Garcia? Pleaaase....

So, to all of these anti chavistas out there, just sit down and watch, the show is getting very interesting, be it the poor Globo journalist agressed by an exasperated Chavez who seems to be missing a few moves lately to the meat shortage at the grocery store (well, I am semi vegetarian so I can laugh at it). All great fun, while we figure out a way out of this increasingly nightmarish situation.


-The end-

Sunday, March 04, 2007

What Venezuelans voted for: lousy public education

One of the most vaunted Chavez prowess among the sycophantic and not so sycophantic crowds that support him is that Chavez is making education available to all, and that through his Mision Robinson, Ribas and Sucre he allows many people to be reincorporated inside the educational system, stop being illiterate and eventually get some form of college degree. Well, maybe.

The table below, taking from today’s El Nacional Web site tells us a very different story.


Yes, even if you cannot understand Spanish well, you did see that school rolls in Venezuela decreased by 585 000, that is a 7.26% points from the highest figure of 2004-2005. Down to 7 486 191 from 8 071 959 in 2004-2005. These numbers, we are told by El Nacional, are taken directly from the accounts and justification memo of the Education Ministry.

Huh? Less kids suddenly? That many less kids suddenly? Was there a war, an epidemic or something?

The article is not very helpful in explaining why such a stunning result. The only thing it tells us is that to find such a sharp drop in education enrollment we must go back to 1994 where a 1.8% drop was observed (during the banking crisis of Caldera II, where at least there was a economic reason whereas between 2005 and 2006 supposedly we were witnessing the Chavez economical miracle, at least according to some!). It also reminds readers that Chavez in public stated that his administration was educating 16 million students, more than double of what the Education Ministry acknowledges. Will a journalist dare to ask Chavez on such a contradiction?

Some possible reasons

The most benign one, that the accounting of the ministry of education is so sloppy that it forgot to include the Misiones enrollment. Note: these misiones are supposedly designed for people who fell OUT of the system earlier and wish to come back into it; thus we are mostly talking about adults in the misiones. The ministry results are supposedly representing the “normal “ school rolls.

The worse explanation of course is that the lack of real jobs and the fake recovery can be clearly seen in the drop in school enrollment. People simply cannot afford to enroll their kids or worse, need them to help scavenge for food and survival…

A more serious charge could be that many parents are getting weary of a public education which looks more and more like a brainwashing system to create the new "socialo-bolivarian man" or some like crazy idea. Private school could become an alternative to the "Escuela Bolivariana".

I will let the reader decide and inquire further, however there is an incredible telling sign that the Venezuelan educational public system is failing, and badly failing. If we look at the figures the drop for the public sector is in fact 9.61%, HIGHER than the global 7.26% reported above. Meanwhile the private sector of education INCREASES its enrollment by 23.96%!!!!!! In a single year!!!! This stunning increase can only be explained one way: quality in public education keeps going down and/or parents refuse to have their kids brain washed in public schools.

Now, I did read this after I read and translated Milagros Socorro Op-Ed piece which I just posted below. The question is of course what would happen to these numbers once the study of Chavez thoughts from his prodigious intellect are made required course work in public education? Will parents vote with their kids feet toward private education?

No wonder a few days ago we heard again the threat of intervening private education (at least in universities but for the past two years there have been constant threats to at least force some "bolivarian" curricula in private schools). It is one way to resist chavismo, to enroll your kids in private education, if you can afford it. And as usual the victims are the poor who cannot escape public education and must leave their kids there, no matter how awful that education might be. Their other choice eventually becoming school desertion. So much for Bolivarian Schools so widely advertised during the 2006 campaign just as kids dropped out in droves.

Stunning!

PS: note added later. The evolution of school rolls can be found here, pre 2004 and here further in the past. These trends seem to indicate that the drop reproted in El Nacional might be a real drop if not quite verifiable as posted in the comment section. Weird!

-The end-

How to deal with chavismo: taking them at their word

Considering that us, poor souls of the opposition seem to be condemned to have to bear Chavez, chavismo and chavistas for quite a while, I have been musing on how to write some form of post, manual, handbook or even field guide, to help the readers of this blog to deal with that cross on our shoulders. Today reading Milagros Socorro latest article I found the format I wanted: one item at a time. That is I will start a new feature such as the one I started sometime in December “What Venezuelans voted for”. Each time I will try to help people by suggesting a way to make the dark night of chavismo more bearable. I hope it helps.

--- --- --- ---

In today’s OpEd piece Ms. Socorro takes a shot at Maria de Queipo, assembly woman from Zulia state. In this state, the current governor Rosales, will be out one way or the other within two years. With a bought out country and a biased electoral system it is all but certain that a chavista will replace Rosales as elections will be a mere formality to ratify Chavez choice. Thus the wanna-be governors are already lining up and sucking up to the Beloved Great Leader to get the nod, the only vote that really matters. Maria’s latest occurrence as placed up quite well in that race and Milagros Socorro makes great fun of it today [my comments when necessary to clarify since it is a humoristic piece that might not be easy to get for the non Venezuelan]. Original in Spanish here, translation below.

We want this program, now
El Nacional, Sunday March 4, 2007

I propose that we take seriously the project of Maria de Queipo, president of the Education Commission of the National Assembly, “to study the thought of Chavez in the schools, the universities, the misiones”. I have taken it very seriously, because if representative Queipo had formulated her initiative to include the philosophical corpus of president Chavez in the programs of formation of the young people of the Republic without the real intention to make reality this purpose, then we would be before a case of flagrant flattery, a vice that is characterized to flatter a person with the objective of receiving in return some benefit, as it could be the one of receiving backing for a possible candidacy to the governorship of Zulia.

And that is discarded, because in the same interview in which Queipo deputy staggered the country with her motion, she defined herself like as a seraphic creature, born in a homestead and vaccinated against the neoliberal model by her “closeness to nature”. In addition, professor Queipo drives a 350 truck [Ford semi heavy duty trucks in Venezuela], as we were told in February of 2005, when an explosive device burst in front of the seat of the MVR in Maracaibo, and hit against this truck, of her property, that was parked there. Who could imagine that an individual who gets her hair wind messed in a 350 will incur in flatteries with the purpose of obtaining some privilege from the flattered person?

The other thing is that university professor Queipo uses the familiar you with president Chavez [in Spanish there are two forms for you, the polite/formal Usted and the familiar Tú], as witness the transcript of the Alo, Presidente N° 182, of the 15 of February of 2004, in that the Chief of State called on her to confirm that his government has been fabulous in Zulia, which she ratifies, underlining her words with “como tú dices” [as you say ]; and hastening to assure to him that the State House of that state is a done deal, that already general Gutierrez could start moving into the Palacio de las Aguilas, since it would not be “very difficult to take the governor seat of Zulia, because we are in front of a coup monger” (she refers to Manuel Rosales, not to the one, undeniably, she has in front of her).

Such friendly treatment annuls the possibility that the professor is going to incur flattery and with it to suggest, God forbid, that in Venezuela ascent in the political scale could depend on the support of a single person, in a this case such a key thinker for the national instruction. Even less that the flattery is effective because the flattered personage demands the protocol of crawling to accede to his favors. It is not conceivable that somebody believes, simultaneously, that the chief executive is source of a thinking of unavoidable debate in the classrooms and also that his will could vary through a good obsequiousness at the right time.

With complete certainty, Maria de Queipo, who has gone ahead to her possible competitors exhibiting her expertise in wise people matters, knows the reflections of smaller figures such as Locke, who established that flattery is a kind of breach of trust, in that the flatterer induces the self deceit of the flattered one, attributing to him capacities or virtues which he lacks with the purpose of gaining some advantage. Of course Locke, who at the end is no more than a smart boy in comparison with the scholar whom we are dealing with, centered his considerations on a political regime with limited and separate powers, in contrast with an absolute regime, where the flattery is a line of business because “those that aspire to obtain excessive power” are susceptible to flattery as flatterers come to stoke up their passion for absolute power.

But let’s leave this. The obsequiousness only finds ground to grow where reigns so excessive a pride and so susceptible to flatteries that then it is unable to detect the ridicule to which the flatterer exposes its recipient. And there is no reason to think this in the case of professor Queipo and, by all means, of the supreme thinker to be studied.

Nevertheless, there is not lack of malicious minds that have insinuated that with her proposal assemblywoman Queipo has put herself, in equestrian terms, in forbidden thirds; that is to say, she has placed an unbridgeable advance from the pack of flatterers. There is only one way to end the giggles and the murmurings. Professor Queipo must stop the commentaries respecting the casualness of her proposal and the rumors that give her a covert will to garner sponsorships through lies.

And this will only happen when professor Queipo presents to the country a complete plan, where the contents of the study program of the thoughts of president Chavez are presented. Well detailed. Of course, for this she will have to read all texts of the luminary. Absolutely all of them, no one knows where may be the luminous phrase, the founding concept, the enlightening notion.

And she must do it herself, she cannot delegate the search and, by the way, the honor. When we have that document, our apprehensions will be over.


Saturday, March 03, 2007

Today's recommended reading on Venezuela


I had been thinking about a summary article about the fast changing outlook in the Venezuela situation now that Chavez has disposed of Jose Vicente Range and that he goes unhinged about his business of Supremo building. But procrastination pays and Gustavo Coronel has an excellent and complete piece that tells us "por donde vienen los tiros" (from where the shots are coming from). Do not miss it. The crumbling Hugo Chávez power equation.

PS: Oh! and do not miss this lovely editorial of the Post on one of Chavez favorite friends and role models, Putin. Could it be the type of nominations that Chavez has in mind to control Venezuela? Heck, he already gave us for Vice President that graduate from the Hannibal Lecter School of Psychiatry...

-The end-

Friday, March 02, 2007

An exercise in history rewriting: February 27

Tuesday Venezuela “commemorated” February 27 1989. Well, some people in fact seemed to celebrate it and are very actively trying to make that date the starting point for the chavista era. Though a preposterous argument, it is interesting to visit the issue as it illustrates quite well how the hagiography and history retelling operate under authoritarian regimes, even if they are of the banana republic type.

February 27, El Caracazo

For the newcomer to Venezuela let’s summarize briefly. After years of relative deprivation and economic hardship, the failed policies of Carlos Andres Perez 1 (CAP 1), Herrera and Lusinchi had brought to office a new government who had decided to apply some more neo liberal tools to try to solve the problem of no growth, persistent inflation and general decrepitude of the country. Unfortunately CAP 2 was elected the in December 1988 on a platform that suggested much more the return of good times and easy money such as during the CAP 1 years than the draconian plan (by Venezuelan standards) that he had decided to apply.

This by itself would not have been so bad if some measures to protect the lowest social groups had been taken. But CAP, his authoritarian self only matched by Chavez, decided to go ahead before the whole plan was duly explained and before any social protection measure was announced in a convincing way. Thus a gas price hike was announced and bus drivers were not told yet whether suburban bus fares would be increased or whether they would receive some subsidy. They of course decided to increase bus fares anyway, people got upset, they started burning buses in Guarenas and soon enough as TV was showing live the disaster of Guarenas this riot took all over the country.

This spontaneous rioting turned out quickly into a massive sacking of stores all across Venezuela. While a minority had the time of their lives the immense majority of Venezuelans rushed back home to hide in fear expecting the slums to knock at their doors, if polite. CAP had to launch the army to restore order and the army, as ill trained as they always are to restore public order, started shooting happily. Now, looting is one thing and being shot at for looting is another thing. Debate can be endless on these matters but what aggravated the situation is that the army got carried away and more than likely some units decided to take the opportunity to eliminate some “undesirables”. Many “mistakes” also were made as a few innocents at the wrong place and the wrong time ended up in mass graves. The death toll will never been known. Officially it is in the few hundred of people, allegedly it could be way above the 1000 mark. What is certain is that after 18 years only a tiny fraction of the potential abuses has been duly investigated, and even less judged and condemned (looters and soldiers alike it must be said).

Lessons of February 27

The first thing to understand is that the movement started as a spontaneous uprising or irked suburbanites who simply could not stand a bus fare increase. That within a few hours a few organized subversives, inherited from the then distant guerilla years, joined by some gangs finding a good opportunity to do dome looting, started fishing in trouble waters is quite possible. But the Venezuelan left in 1989 was at its lowest point ever, and certainly not able at all to organize rioting on that scale. Organized crime on the other hand would have stood a much better chance to coordinate some of these events.

However, the day marks definitely a cleavage in Venezuelan history. Until that date Venezuela had lived through 4 decades of relative peace and quiet and internal order. Yes, there was the overthrow of Perez Jimenez in 1958, and the guerilla of the 60ies, but for the immense majority of Venezuelans, for the 4 decades that preceded el Caracazo if you were not into politics and if you were not into organized crime you could have a fairly decent life as far as personal security, peace and quiet were concerned. Since 1989 violence has climbed steadily and has even reached Miraflores where verbal violence is now the norm of government, a telling omen of what is ahead for us. Any gentility in Venezuela was crushed on February 27 1989 and since then we have been living in increasing fear, a fear exploited by all sorts of politicians from Caldera 2 to Chavez. To their great everlasting shame of course but unfortunately atonement will happen years from now.

There was also some collateral effect to that day. TV was abundantly accused of promoting looting by showing images of how easy it was to loot, how absent were security forces from the streets before CAP decided to send in the army. This has generated a sort of self censorship within TV from then on, which includes April 13 2002 when the looting that was taking place in some of Caracas areas was not shown, nor the few people that were claiming for Chavez return.

The army decided that it was not going to be punished for its abuses. Thus 1989 starts the return of the army as something that could not be touched by the political power, bringing us to what is now a military regime disguised behind the Chavez election. After 8 years of rule Chavez has done very little to correct for the 1989 abuses, and even less to avoid a reoccurrence of such an event. But the army is now in charge in way that it was not in charge since even Perez Jimenez time! Katy is not even afraid of talking of a military cover up as many of today’s “public servants” were obeying orders in 1989 and nobody knows exactly what they did then.

Recuperating February 27 1989

But beyond national regret or military cover up what is perhaps most indecent is trying to make El Caracazo look like what it is not. And chavismo has been hard at work since it reached office in transforming that date as the original date of the Bolivarian revolution. Certainly it is more palatable than the 1992 coup by Chavez. And it could well excuse the coup if the collective in Venezuela were to embrace El Caracazo. But this has not happened yet, no matter how hard chavismo has tried to appropriate for itself a date where it had nothing, absolutely nothing, to do, even as Chavez and his little pals were already plotting.

But the regime has been trying to build a golden legend for people who were raised in the safety of the hated 4th Republic educational system, who did not have to pay much for their military education, and who were allowed to run for president 5 years after they had tried a coup d’etat. No grand epic there. So we must invent one.

The basic problem is to erase the “illegal” side of 1992. That is where El Caracazo comes in handy. If we accept that premise that February 27 1989 was the starting point of a popular sentiment for political reform, then it can be argued that the 1992 coup was a natural consequence by some politically enlightened officers. Unfortunately this cheap revisionism does not work well outside of hard core chavista radical core. Too many people still remember that day and too many people remember personally, or know of people, hiding at home and putting mattresses against the windows to stop bullets. Too many people also remember that shopping malls were ransacked even in middle and upper class neighborhoods too far from popular districts to have a significant crowd coming form there: how could they carry back home the loot? Nobody remembers people lining up to march against Miraflores to unseat CAP who had just been reelected 2 months before by way more votes than Chavez ever got, that is until Chavez managed to manipulate the electoral rolls enough last year.

Facts are hard sometimes…

But that does not stop chavismo to try every year since it took Miraflores and everything else. After all, what is a second month of the year riot for someone who is revising the whole colonial history of Venezuela to adapt it to a concept that even Marx in a drunken stupor would not have penned. So we saw the National Assembly on Tuesday gathering for an outdoor session to proclaim that from now on February 27 would be Human Rights day in Venezuela. Huh? Is there no other more suitable date to commemorate Human Rights in Venezuela? Even December 15 1999 would be better as it would commemorate the expansion of Human Rights in the Venezuelan constitution. That they are not applied is another matter but for then on they were written on pseudo stone.

However there are also other things to mask. For example Chavez has its own repressive February 27 in 2004. Something that he is managing to get forgotten up to a point, but that day he had a few people killed, you know. You can check the posts from February 27 and 28 in of this blog to refresh your memory.

He also has to make forget that the so much vaunted 1999 constitution is now been overhauled largely without any public debate, just a group of chavista yes-people secretly preparing a revised draft to present to Chavez. Participation is now a dead letter in Venezuela even if the words still might appear in the constitution after its changes.

The fun moment

But as usual chavismo provides us with the comic relief.

There are many mediocrities in chavismo who think that they are great folks, tending to forget that if they are where they are it is strictly because of Chavez. One of them is the Miranda state governor, Diosdado Cabello. In all truth within chavismo he is one of the few that have demonstrated that they have some modest managerial skills. Now that he is in charge of the second biggest state of the country his skills are seriously challenged and he seems to have reached his level of incompetence according to Peter’s principle.

So, to create a stunt and come back to public light (chavista sent him to Miranda as he was taking too much weight inside the government and Chavez does not like any luminary around him, no matter how faint that one might be) Diosdado decided to change a district name. He decided to change the popular neighborhood name of the Guarenas district called Menca de Leoni. The new name? “27 de febrero”!

Unfortunately the folks around protested even if they probably voted overwhelmingly for Chavez, and even if the original riot started from that same district 18 years ago. See, not only many folks living in that district are still embarrassed that this great stain in Venezuelan history started among its men folk mostly, but they also remember even if vaguely Menca de Leoni. She was the wife of Raul Leoni who served between 1963 and 1968. Arguably he is the best president of the so ill called 4th republic. During his tenure he had to face violent guerilla but he managed to consolidate the nascent democracy to the point that in 1968 for the first time the opposition received power after winning an election. Something unheard of in Venezuelan history. And his wife was one of the most famous first ladies of the era, probably the one with the highest social concern of the lot, including Marisabel de Chavez, now enjoying a life of riches in Barquisimeto far from any ghetto where Menca had no fear in visiting.

But such are things in the Bolivarian revolution.

I remember as one of my first political memories the funeral of Menca de Leoni. I was impressed that young by the crowd that was following the hearse. I was even more impressed that my mother who never had a kind word for Leoni (she voted for Uslar) was actually sad watching the hearse passing by. I am sure that Diosdado does not remember Menca, nor does he care for that matter. Then again what kind of general education did Diosdado receive in the military barracks where he let Chavez bewitch him? That is why he made a total fool of himself this week, trying to go back to public notice, trying to please Chavez, trying to think that he also could rewrite history. Alas, he is only the governor of Miranda state, happily erasing anything that was done before by way more competent people than he is. I suppose that he expects that erasing the past people will not notice what a lousy governor he is turning out to be.

When everything is said and done, the more mediocre you are the more you need to rewrite history. This is exactly what we are witnessing, the normal course of any medirocre authoritarian state on its ways to some form of totalitarianism.

Followers