Thursday, March 18, 2010

Health Care in Venezuela: even the private sector lags

Chavista propaganda would like us to believe that health care in Venezuela is the best.  Well, it is not and we know that from nay sources, from the number of "barrio adentro" modules that are closed to the pitiful condition of public hospitals which are of public knowledge.  But today I got some even more worrisome news: even private medicine in Venezuela is decaying fast so even if you have money and heath insurance, well, you have few choices.

My twitter brought me though Decifrado this link from America Economia which lists the 20 bests health centers in Latin America, from private clinics to public hospitals and teaching universities.  Venezuela has only one clinic ranked, Clinica Metropolitana, which readers should remember from the travails that yours truly endured there.  In a way I am happy because this conforms to me that my appreciation of Clinica Metropolitana as a top institution in spite of all the miseries faced to operate in a country ruled by incompetence.  But look at the table some more and you will start wondering....  

  • For example Colombia has 5 institutions, Venezuela only one.
  • Clinica Metropolitana is one of the smallest in bed numbers: 136, while just in Chile, with 3 ranked institutes, counts more than 1100 beds.
  • Two public hospitals do make it tot he ranking, one in Medellin and one in San Jose, Costa Rica.  Tiny Costa Rica also gets the number 5 slot with a private clinic....

It is to be noted that Clinica Metropoliana ranked dead last  that the item "patient security" which is an index that deals with ethics, to confidentiality and transparency, from reception at the ER to information.  I can understand that personally since the clinic is simply overwhelmed by the amount of people who try to check in and as such personalized patient following cannot be good.  Unfortunately for Metropolitana, it was one of the biggest index to establish the general ranking.

How can we explain that Venezuela with so much oil energy and such vaunted health plans can only manage to have a small private hospital to make it to the top 20?  And an hospital already built in 1970.

The date is the secret: Clinica Metropolitana is in fact one of the last major health center built in Caracas (I think that only the complex at La Trinidad follows, though several smaller clinics have opened).  Under Chavez no major private health center has been opened, or even public ones for that matter as the only thing to note is the Children Cardio Center which is not very big to begin with.

People are not going to invest in private heath center, even though the market exists as can be seen by the overcrowding of the places that make them look like public hospitals!  Why that lack of investment?

  • The chavista government has not helped private institutions to invest to try to compensate at least in part the deficit of the public sector.  It is not for the state to build these of course, but at least to give tax credits, credits, prepared medical personnel t staff these centers, etc, etc...  All what chavismo has done is to graduate under par medics in Cuba that none of these centers would hire even for bed pan duty.
  • The government has instead relied on private health insurance for many of its employees who do not attend the public sector.  The concentration of government investment in primary care exclusively for electoral purposes has for result the crowding of private facilities, killing competition and need to invest since they are minting as it is.
  • The constant threats of Chavez to nationalize everything, coupled to the real time observation of the continuous overall degradation of the public health sector makes the owners of private clinics and hospitals know full well that when the situation of the public sector becomes catastrophic Chavez will simply nationalize the private sector facilities to replace the ruined hospitals he is unable to fix adequately.  Why invest for Chavez to enjoy the results?
The fact f the matter is that for some honorable exceptions (for propaganda purposes?) Chavez personnel has been unable in 11 years to build a true comprehensive health care, amen of keeping up the one which already existed for all of its faults.  And yet for ideological reasons he has not been able to sit down with the private sector to try to allow this one to pick up the slack so at least all those who can afford it could go to private institutions and free public resources.  The paradox now is that under a socialist revolution we are everyday told of families of humble resources who go into final destitution to try to save a loved ne because the local public hospital is, well, worthless.  How often at work we have had to chip in to help buy this or that for someone surgery or treatment....

Ad that my friends is the reality of the Venezuelan heath care system, confirmed strangely through this page of America Economia where only one relatively small Venezuelan institution manages to figure...  True, some public hospitals have newer equipments, have been restored, etc...  but what matters the most, access, seems not to have improved since 1998 while access to private health care has degraded.


  1. 1979 Boat People9:03 PM

    Does any hospitals in Cuba under the Castro regime make the list?

    If NO then we need kick Michael Moore's fat ASS.

  2. 1979 Boat People10:47 PM

    VERY OT:

    Hope that Daniel does not mind and let me post it here.

    Researchers create 3-D invisibility cloak: study

  3. BoatPeople,

    We know it is not OT. I was about to write to Daniel about that too: if he wants to stay in Venezuela, the invisibility cloak may be a solution. But it is still several years ahead before it becomes a market product.

    Meanwhile he could go to France and spend some time there. Daniel, don't you have relatives there? I know the economy is not doing so well there (same here, perhaps better on this side of Belgium) and it is extremely restrictive compared to the US's, but you may find it incredibly liberal (in the European sense) compared to Venezuela.
    A summer in the Provence n'est pas mal, quoi.

  4. Well, I can't say this is surprising. Name one area of business which has actually prospered under Chavez. Heck, I'd be surprised if someone could name an area which has pretty much maintained its level over that period of time. (For those who want to suck up to Hugo, that's not an individual business, but a specific sector, meaning all businesses of a given type collectively.) About the only possible area would be "gestores," the people who help you navigate a given government bureaucracy (like getting your DNI, passport, CADIVI money), and we all know that's not something you can call "productivity."

  5. Anonymous1:39 PM

    A good health care system does not appear overnight but takes years of development. Medical schools, facilities, hospitals, staff training, etc will not appear instantly when Chavez is flushed from office. Chavez destruction of Venezuela health care will hurt generations to come.

  6. 1979 Boat People9:25 PM


    When such a product is available, Thugo Chavez is the first person to order a dozens for himself so that he:

    1) Can Sleep well at night.

    2) Wandering the streets day and night to....who knows...any thing is possible with Hugo.

  7. Roger2:23 AM

    Key to health care in Venezuela are the doctors and others who make hospitals work. For years now many have been voting with their feet! This is also true of all professional fields. It's called Brain Drain and it is perhaps the worst in LatAm!

  8. OT PSF Alert!

    Cindy Sheehan is coming back to Venezuela to defend the revolution. Apparently her organization "Peace of the Action" has got a piece of the action! Wonder what her cut is?

  9. Glen,

    A quote from Sheehan:

    "Often when I go to events here in the US, many Obama supporters are in attendance, and I put all my cards on the table at once and I say: “I am not here to praise Obama, and I am not here to bury him, either—I am here to tell the truth.”

    One can say the a human being can be divided into 2 parts.:

    1.the real inner self( the essence)
    2.the less real to totally false outer persona( the personality)

    In the case of Cindy Sheehan I could safely say that her most distinguishing quality is that she does not exist.


Comments policy:

1) Comments are moderated after the sixth day of publication. It may take up to a day or two for your note to appear then.

2) Your post will appear if you follow the basic polite rules of discourse. I will be ruthless in erasing, as well as those who replied to any off rule comment.